Director
John Tindall
DIRECTOR
Stars (in credits order)
Geoff Pierson
Self - Host
Tomas Johansson
Detective Ted Keech
David Donah
Sheriff of gainsville county
Jordan Lawson
Bar Patron
Gabriel Lemus
Ballistic Lab Technician
Tom Wade
Bill Heyliger
Christopher L. Robinson
Detective Keith Barton
Calvin Dean
Tom Bailey
Malcolm Matthews
Neighbor
Joe O'Dell
Bill Cosco
Britt Prentice
Detective Chalmers
Wil Crown
Detective Dennis
Christopher Lavigne
Bartender
Jake Ferree
Detective #1
Arthur Richardson
Anthony Guy Walker
Madeleine Falk
Crystal Beelen
Dave Bean
Det. Brent Benzing
Joseph Integlia
Crime Scene Investigator
Mike Burnell
(older) Paul Rowles
Kevin Scott Allen
Mateo Judson
Dani Marie
CSI
Tim Hooper
Detective Anderson
Steven T. Bartlett
Hawthorne PD Detective
William Guirola
Body guard
Meghan McGarry
Elizabeth
Abraham Luna
Hernandez
Al LaFleur
Detective Andretti
Chuck Saale
Officer Gilbert
Rosemary Brownlow
Doctor's Daughter
Katie Freeman
Bar Patron #3
Martin Sottile
Goodwin's Attorney
Kira Reed Lorsch
Detective Sharon Feola
Matthew Gilmore
Detective Bill Shaw
Kimberly Spak
Jill Kinkade
Shannon Lee Holmes
Dottie's Friend
Mark Child
Tim Jankowski
Maria Elena Heredia
Sketch Artist
Jamie Avera
Detective Joe Coyle
Kristen Hagen
Lab Tech Smith
Deja Soufka
Luis
Lee Schall
Older Bobby
Luis Alberto Aracena
Sheriff
Ryan Bouton
Alex
Rob Sheens
Dennis Ryan Forensic NY
Cory Storey
Bar Patron 2
Daniel Evich
Poker Player
Robert Dominick Jones
Morey Weiss
James MacPherson
Budd
Matt Weinglass
Detective Waddill
James Hal Hardy
Robert Haggart
Darrell Philip
Haggart
Jim Jepson
Detective Lt. Craig Chrzanowski
Manuel Domenech
Nick
Christian Matthew Toma
Young Lou
Arielle Hader
Marcia Johnson
Matt Fowler
Detective Gary Rothwell
Claire Montgomery
Sandy Bailey
Brant Rotnem
Detective Jon Holland
Lawrence Moran
Jim Lindeman
Kevin L. Walker
Andrew 'Melvin' Weathers
John Prudhont
Commander Barrett Vassall
Jimmy McCarthy
Older Mason
Lyle Friederichs
Professor Merbs
Christopher Robert Gray
Detective Davis
Jason Freeley
Young Jonas
Rachel Alig
Reyna
Erin Leigh Neumeyer
Forensic Anthropologist
Johnny La
Jian Chu
Julie Nolan
Kelly Corbin
Tommy Kijas
Young Gantman
Brendan Connor
Prosecutor Levine
Mark Belnick
Archeologist
Janna Cardia
District Attorney Isherwood
Zach Winegard
Young Jon
Tom McLaren
Mason's Defense Attorney
Michelle Haro
Court Reporter
Ray Peavy
Self - Captain, Los Angeles Country Sheriff's Dept.
Donald Prince
Gordon Eckert
Tierra Luckey
Street Person #2
Cruz Flores
Car Buyer
Christine Sinacore
Missouri Resident #1
Matthew Dennis Lewis
Carson Shack
Aaron Groben
Druggie Suspect
Robyn Von Arx
Detective Venus Repper
Jetta Juriansz
Beth Foster's Roommate
Robert L. Greene
Older richard archibeque
Joseph Alfieri
Contractor Foreman
Lauren Lakis
1979 Victim
Audrey Ellis Fox
Linda
Baker Chase Powell
Roger Canares
Kelly Hancock
Cheryl Murphee
Ashley Undercuffler
Megan
Laura Elizabeth Hall
Deb Hill
Anthony Nuccio
Police Officer
Angie Teodora Dick
Yolanda
Edward Kasper
Biker
Gayla Johnson
Sarah
Kylee Wofford
Sonja
Anna Ross
High School Girl
Adam Finley
Carl Jenkins
Katy Foley
Younger Cheryl
John Zacchino
Carl Epson
Dylan John Seaton
Ryan Wyngarden
Timothy J. Richardson
Kidnapper 1
Michael Justice
Brian Trufford
Mark Schaefer
Detective Blakely
Isabelle Loeb
Mary Quigley
Sam Skolnik
Friend of victim
John Woodruff
Paul Rowles
David A. Garcia
Lt. Highnight
Jason Gregory London
Young Keith Kerns
Carly Van Skaik
Tiffany Sessions
Randy Lee
Detective
Matt Stoner
Robert Carey
James Radcliffe
Prosecutor Mesman
Tori La Desma
Theresa Carey
Lizzie Hartman
Younger Bernice
Ray Chao
Officer Martinez
July Vega
Richard Archibeque
Sadie Darnell
Self - Sheriff, Alachua County
Yana Trofimova
High school girl
Craig Cooper
Sergeant Terry Collins
Michael Marrio
Desk Sergeant
Dee Smith
Polygraph Examiner
Gerald Mack
Cop 3
Austin James Horick
Patrick Sessions
Jennifer Buttell
Older Pam Wyngarden
James Francisco
Self - Lt., Highland Park Police Dept. (Ret.)
Harriet Fisher
Office Girl
Shondale Seymour
Isla Brink
Brandy Zapata
Beth
Betty White
Self - Louise's Sister
Wayne Black
Self - Private Investigator
Joe Swickard
Self - Reporter, Detroit Free Press
Brianna Berlen
Emma
Cheryl Murphree
Self - Gails Sister
Jim Fath
Polygrapher
Lauren Wassink
Self - 'Sam' - Det., Ottawa County Sheriff's Office
Budd Brink
Self - Rick's Brother
Kenny Mack
Self - Det., Alachua County Sheriff's Office
Pat Sessions
Self - Tiffany's Father
Hilary Sessions
Self - Tiffany's Mother
Kirsten Roquemore
Mrs. Carey
Venus Repper
Self - Det., Ottawa County Sheriff's Office
Tim Clifton
Profiler
Melissa Kountz
Self
Lee Fisher
Self - Ass. Prosecuting Atty., Ottawa County
Blair Shapiro
Janice Goodman
Paul Thomas
Detective, Highland Park Police Dept.
David Blakely
Carl Zauner
Cop
Ashley Rose Reedy
Young Pam
Krista Milis
Office Woman
Chad Curtis Wood
Prosecutor Fisher
Prisilla Weckesser
Kathryn
Rick Galiher
Old Keith Kearns
Michael Lutheran
Rick Brink
Jakob Zermeno
Friend
David Truax
Detective Kenny Mack
Stephanie Sanditz
Susan
Meredith Thomas
Dottie Hermance Apgar
Jess Matney
Cop #4
Steve Richard Harris
Heath Centazzo
Darren Sellers
Alex Barone
Officer Phillips
Konstantin Melikhov
Tasha Dixon
Anna Zemke
Ian Stanley
Prison Guard
Jason Caceres
James
Tim Parrish
Jim Meade
Silvia Spross
Carol
Tim Lacatena
David
Jasper Sams
Lisa Holman
Brian Hanford
Carl Davis
Mindy Montavon
Lisa Martin
Darren Kendrick
Detective Smythe
Korbin Miles
Scott Smith
Greg Lutz
Prosecutor Thomas Eagon
Niko Papastefanou
Tom Parton
Julia Farino
FBI Investigator
David Alan Graf
State Investigator #1
Heather McPhaul
Kathy Johnson
Derek Ocampo
Swat #2
Bryan Casserly
Detective Borkenhagen
Justin Nesbitt
Sica
Alana Kerr Collins
Elaine McCollum
Kurt Oberhaus
Younger Detective Hylton
Hari Williams
Young Walker
Robert Artz
Bernard Green
Desiree Louise
Lorraine
Kurt Tocci
Buddy #1
Michael Cline
Homeowner
Skipper Elekwachi
John Madison
Lindsey Hutchison
Mrs. Benson
Justin Phillip
Young Marvin
Gregory Pekar
Older Mark
Nicholas Luna
Whittaker
Patty Sherman
Jeff Houkal
Detective Pimentel
Fatimah Taliah
Medical Examiner Assistant
Liam Fountain
Deputy Nelson
Meredith Parks
Marcina
Megan Hui
Mei Chung
Postal Worker
Jason McBeth
Detective Lockerby
Adrian Bustamante
Sheriff #1
Kate Froehlich
Factory Woman #1
Chase Matthews
Greg Martin
Lexi Flores
Hamburger Clerk Jackie
J.R. Ritcherson
Clearwater Investigator
Eddie Aguirre
Cop #1
Rebecca Both
Detective Waddill's Wife
Razor Rizzotti
Police Officer Diaz
Doug Heiar
Kidnapper
Presley A. Aronson
Gregg Holman
Florence C.M. Klein
Bill's Mother
John Wusah
Medical Examiner
Adam Weber
Young Mark
Nathaniel Meek
John K. Frazier
Ben Kacsandi
Bobby Dunes
Hugh Lehane
David Allen Gerrard
Ian Watson
Rick Silver
Detective Sanders
David Namminga
Mechanic
David Madwin
Eddie Arndt
Parker Brightman
Little Bobby
Michael Hampton
Detective Figurski
Jon E. Darby
Best Friend Scott
Boriana Williams
Friend of Victim
Brian Graham
Hunter
Michael Kunselman
Vann Tate
Robert Burton
Detective, 1957
Joshua Verges
Gerald Mason
Ryan Karloff
Friend #1
Bradley Hawkins
Older Walter Spence
Tess Hanna
Young Beth
Bryan Hanna
Loading Dock
Leah Caruana
McMullen's Wife
Eliezer Ortiz
Mike
George Stumpf
Jeff Lobik
Karen Ann Pavlick
Shirley
Julian Bane
Detective Hayden
Jody Hart
Sheriff Scott
Brandy Bryant
Cop #5
Michael Goyeneche
Charlie
Phillip Kent Helser
John Foster
Rob Nolan
Older Lou
Logan Dondanville
Jon's Little Brother
James Jeffery Caldwell
John Carrol
Ashley Murray
Young Wallace Spence
Richard Van Slyke
Jennifer Gable
CSI Detective
Mark Blydel
Mr. Benson
Ian Davids
Quint
Patrick Birman
Robert Edwards
Brian Ide
Brian Siebrandt
Hugh Lockerby
Self - Det., Violent Crimes, Scottsdale P.D.
Lisa Garrett
Wife
Stephen Todt
Teenager #2
Charles Reccardo
Cashier
Freddie De Grate
Fingerprint Expert
Peter McGlynn
Older Jon
Nora Foley
Woman in the Pool Hall
Will Brunson
Det. John McCoy
TJ Johnson
Construction Foreman
Shannon Simone Miller
Niece of Gerlad Mason
Steve Phelan
Detective Lane Youmans
Robert Javinett
County Attorney
Sean Michael Nugent
Brian Parpan
Jared Pettit
1977 Cop
Mel Wingfield
Georgia Detective
Sam Anderson
Cop #3
Michael Ernst
Self - Special Agent, Illinois State Police (ret.)
Lex Kilgour
Garnetta Haggart
Eddy Mizner
Police Searcher #1
Isaac Anderson
John
Lou Chardell
Self - Greg Holman's Classmate
G. Brian Benson
DA Thomas McLaughlin
Elise D'Orazio
Chris Hernando
YMCA Clerk
Linda Sherdel
CSI Investigator 1
William T. Bayley
Angry Boyfriend
Dave Crossland
Sora
Anais Ford
Todd Carlton Lanker
Walter the Tipster
Adam Daniel
CSI Hood
Jake Lane Bassi
Jeff Lobik (Younger)
Brian Nocella
David A. Jørgensen
Marc Oldroyd
Zach Mirer
Swat Guy
Kendall Mayhew
Frankie
Darren Andrew Nash
Sheriff McNutt
Larry Hood
Self - Sr. Crime Analyst, Illinois State Police (ret.)
David van den Berg
Lane Youmans
Craig Cleary
Self - Lt., El Segundo Police Dept. (ret.)
Duane Weekly
Roger Reece
Darren Levine
Self - Head Deputy, Los Angeles County, D.A.'s Office
Louis Dezsera
Older Detective Hylton
William Edward Dagsher
Inmate Patterson
Aliza Fassett
Theresa
Craig Chrzanowski
Self - Lt., Violent Crimes, Violent Crimes, Scottsdale P.D.
Shirley M. Cortez
Older Kathy Andrade
Mark Vuncannon
Detective Schweers
Andrea Gentry
Mrs. Post
Jake Bucher
Teenager #1
Ryan McCrary
Officer Davis
Jeffrey M. Hartman
Eugene Clark
Tim McCook
Middle Jon
Nick Chandler
Detective Judkins
Karen Pavlick
Shirley Williams
Caroline Kuta
Harper Eden White
Teenager #4
Hallie Cooper
Bill's Sister
Bernard Bangasser
Self - El Segundo Police Dept. (ret.)
Glenn Rottmann
Rosa Barron
Heather
Michael Valentine Farrens
Detective McMullen
Ilona Concetta
Sketch Artist Alice
Harry Farmer
Hank
Andy Steinhauer
Technician
Naomi Murden
Jon McCoy
Self - Lead Inv., Adams County Sheriff's Dept. (ret.)
Dan Weale
Detective Janiszewski
Barry Vassall
Self - Commander, Scottsdale Police Department
Jonathan Barnard
Self - State's Attorney, Adams County, Illinois
Denim Richards
Shooter #2
Stephen Manley
Police Informant
Arielle Raycene
Girlfriend
Tara Erickson
Susan Brown
Jay Lawrence Kiman
Oscar Jordan
Brian Shakti
Michael Clarke
David Alen
Older Galen 'Shorty' Llode
John Nicholson
Federal Agent
Jose Rosete
Bob Deasy A.K.A. Mr. Big
Krystina Bailey
EMT #1
Steve Hanks
Detective Earl Tripp
Mark Slater
Younger Morey Weiss
Micah Lyons
Jack Wallace
Debby Gerber
Wynn's Girlfriend
Andrea Nelson
Carrie Jones
Holgie Forrester
Aunt Cathy
Tyler Haines
David Tyll
Shelby Janes
Sharon
Julia Coulter
Police Clerk
Dan Spector
Det. Walter Rutherford
Caslin Rose
Linda Chatt
Claudia Zie
Citizen
Nimi Adokiye
Wiretap Tech Operator
Ayanna S. Flemings
Attorney 1
Sean McBride
Bruce Ridley
G. Larry Butler
Older Detective
Ashley Erin Campbell
Townsperson #2
Konstantin Podprugin
Duvall Brother
Jordan Leer
Jim Daniels
Kailena Mai
Inmate
Andy Gates
Mark Lillienfeld
JT Vancollie
Older Kimberly Lloyd
Tory Taranova
Barbara Lloyd
James Adam Tucker
Fire Marshall
Matt Steele
Paul
Jaspreet Sabrina Dosanjh
Stenographer
Justin Andrews
Hypnotist
Monique Filips
Ben Solenberger
Detective Peters
Taryn Leggett
Customer #2
Lauren Hoffmeier
Citizen #2
Mike Shaffrey
Detective Delano
Victor Kamwendo
Shooter #1
Kalina Vanska
Shamrock Patron #3
Burt Culver
JR Duvall
Self - Det., Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department
Everett
Older Joe Lloyd
Melissa Miles
Wife #1
Kerry Wieder
CSI #1
Shannan Leigh Yancsurak
Barmaid
Roy Allen III
Jack Irwin
Mona Mossayeb
Forensic Detective
Brent Harvey
Undercover Cop
Jake T. Getman
Young Joe Lloyd
Jennifer Lynn O'Hara
Nancy Stoltz
Charlotte Rothwell
Secretary
Henry Mark
Lab Technician
Rey Verdugo
Self - Det., Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department (ret.)
Melissa Schumacher
Donna
Rachel Wolf
Pedestrian #2
Jordan Spaulding
Millie and Dave's Bartender
Mary Bold
Waitress
Mannie De Castro
Suspect
Denver Marcus
Client #2
Lindsey Nicole Brooks
CSI Agent #2
Richard Milanesi
Barker
Jes Selane
Steven Michaels
Crash Buist
Deputy
Keith Gallucci
Brian Ognjan
Zack Sayenko
Douglas Halleck
Deanna Pak
Vieng Phovixay
Paul Mitchell Rosenblum
Insurance Executive
Heather Spiegel
Cindy the Waitress
Daniel Kuhlman
Travis Marburger
Alisha Seaton
Barb Clement
JT Alexander
Young Jack Erwin
Mora Carew
Pedestrian #1
Paula Lauzon
Rebecca Lee
Ken Hodges
David Tsuboi
Michael Ray
Attorney General
Dave Klec
Rex Duvall
Ben Leasure
Galan 'Shorty' Lloyd
Sheldon White
Colleen Campbell
Self - Mickey Thompson's Sister
Cheyenne Buchanan
Stephen
Cole Reinhardt
Justin Roberts
Tony Gibbons
Gunman
Siegfried Peters
Robert Anderson
Charles S. Frank
Back Hoe Operator
Kelly McCracken
Detective 1
Paisley Baker
Prosecutor
Matt Laydon
Parole Officer
Robin S. Roth
Motel Owner
Jay Bowdy
Texas Ranger
Daniel Novick
John (Bar Patron)
Laura Downes
Tavarus Weems
Victor Aminger
Doug Harvey
Younger Bill Leggett
Sophia Mayer Pliner
Kimberly Lloyd
Lillian Solange Beaudoin
Denise Tyll
David Silavin
Terry Stroud
Retiree 1-Bobs Friend
Abhay Walia
Cop #2
Eric Schwartz
Creepy bar patron
Ashley Felkner
Jolene Spalding
Daniel Ryan Egan
Ernest Gordon Strowbridge
Giovanni Capitello
Police Officer 1
Gemma Marin
Correctional Officer
Kira Borrowdale
John Katona
Mike Wynn
Nick Savage
Property Vault Sergeant
CJ Brady
John Ogden
Katie Hampton
Receptionist
Shelley Starrett
Detective Sue Peters
Angela Capri
Aunt Nancy
Eric Cutshall
Mr. Wilson
Britain Simons
Teen Tipster
Samantha Rund
Terry Dormer
Gibbons
Maddie Patrick
Young Marie Dupe
August Kensington
Police Officer #1
Grant Newcomb Henderson
Doug Dupe
Will Morgan
Card Player
Charles Gregory Schwartz
Dalila Lutz
Goodwin's Secretary
Sudesh Managodage
Street Person 1
Thomas I. Hall
Lawyer 2
LaTeasha Leigh Clark
Women #1
J.D. Benjamin
Detective Verdugo's Partner
Glenn Fancher
Detective Rey Verdugo
Nick Burr
Cliff Matthews
Melanie Friedrich
Janet
Travis Crookshanks
Investigator
Keith Aaron Jarvis
Suspect #2
Billy Mikus
Det. Constable Mclain
Wes Cheers
Moises Macedo
Operator
Edgar Nentwig
Margaret Cameron Kerr
Customer #3
Alan Jackson
Self - Former Deputy D.A., Los Angeles County
Evan Henderson
Detective Robert Lesneski
Nathaniel Wicks
Meggan Amos
Det. Mary Gugliuzza
Corinne DeVries
Mary
Dyson Posey
Bar Patron 1
Nico Herbst
Citizen #3
Dustin Sturm
Jared Milrad
District Attorney Alan Jackson
Ronald Paul Stevens
Self - Mickey Thompson's Former Neighbor
Justin Lee Wilson
Lead Forensic Investigator
John Alexenko
Preacher (uncredited)
Billy Mayo
Detective Paul Thomas (uncredited)
Brashaad Mayweather
Jimmy (uncredited)
Jameelah Lee
15 year old Kimberly (uncredited)
Stevie Mack
Detective Shaw (uncredited)
Dylan Synclaire
Bosco's Brother (uncredited)
Tiara McKinney
Young Melissa Kountz (uncredited)
Rob Kolinsky
Officer Shwartz (uncredited)
Robert Don
Detective Francisco (uncredited)
Sonya Wallace
Melissa Kountz (uncredited)
Kristopher Mcafee
Officer #5 (uncredited)
Dre Sawyer
Louise (uncredited)
Stephen Paul'Astor
Young William 'Bosco' Lyles Jr. (uncredited)
Kim Kent
Bosco's Mother (uncredited)
Damien Coates
Police Officer (uncredited)
Patrick Shea
Sergeant Lukas (uncredited)