Stars (in credits order)
Alicia Dennis
Self - People Magazine Executive Editorial Director
Jack Walter Coles
Officer #1
Shahrad Fredotti
Gregory Malarik
Christine Pelisek
Self - People Magazine Senior Writer
Matt Murphy
Self - Retired Orange County Senior Deputy DA
Ethan Jones
FBI Agent
Tali Shapiro
Self - Survivor
Cambria Max Goering
Young Tali
Steve Hodel
Self - Retired LAPD Detective
Greg Hanlon
Self - Senior crime news editor
Morgan Rowan
Josefina Rivera
Wendy Naugle
Self - People Magazine Editor-in-Chief
Chuck Peruto
Self - Gary Heidnik's Defense Attorney
James Curless
Self - Retired Detective Lexington PD
Patrick Rogers
Self - People Magazine Senior Editor
Chris Camacho
Self - Retired LAPD Officer
Melody Chiu
Self - People Magazine Executive Editor
Holly Dunn
Sherry Hopson
Samira Asma-Sadeque
Self - People Magazine Staff Writer
Gary Rothwell
Self - Retired Georgia FBI Special Agent in Charge
David Savidge
Self - Retired Philadelphia Police Officer
Kimberley Barkhausen
Self - Retired FBI Special Agent
Annette Lazar
Roy Harris
Self - Retired Georgia FBI Special Agent
Bob Guerrieri
Self - Retired Commander Naperville PD
James Josey
Self - Retired Milledgeville Police Officer
Randy Kennedy
Self - Retired Police Chief
Jim Able
Self - Barbara's Husband
Eleanor Pettis
Self - Barbara's Friend
Sheldon Yavitz
Self - Paul John Knowles's Attorney
Karen Weeks
Self - Witness
Donald Haines
Christopher Loudon
Self - Retired Lisle Police Detective
Liam Quinn
Annie Pollock
Self - Holly's Friend
Barbara Maybee Able
Latoya Rivera
Self - Josefina's Daughter