The Curious Case of Natalia Grace (2023) | Full Cast

Christian Conway

DIRECTOR

Jackson Conway

DIRECTOR

Beth Karas

Self - Legal Expert

Michael Barnett

Self - Natalia's adoptive father

Dan Cody

Michael Barnett

Natalia Barnett

Self

Caitlin McEachran

Kristine Barnett

Nicole DePaul

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive parent

Cynthia Mans

Self - Natalia's Guardian

Kristine Barnett

Self

Jake Barnett

Self

Bishop Anton Mans

Self - Natalia's Guardian

Vince DePaul

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive parent

Terrance Kinnard

Self - Attorney

Rachel Ambler

Self - Barnett's neighbor

Mackenzie DePaul

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive sister

Ava Schlegel

Natalia Grace

Katrina Kemp

Natalia

Bob Cooper

Self - former police detective

Toby Miles

Self - Natalia's neighbor

Kyna Weaver

Self - Lafayette neighbour

Mark Nicholson

Self - Kristine Barnett's defense attorney

Jackie Starbuck

Self - Deputy prosecuting attorney

Michelle Frazee

Self - Family friend

Sue McCallum

Self - Natalia's neighbor

Jackson Goral

Wesley Barnett

Judith Irving

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive mother

Kathy Barnett

Self - Michael's mother

Melanie Miles

Self - Natalia's neighbor

Veronica Maxwell

Self - Retired FBI Special Agent

Eddy Ramey

Self - Former Neighbor and Building Maintenance for the Manses

Freddie Gill

Self

Anna Gava

Self - Natalia's alleged biological mother

Robyn Farris

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive mother

Kimberly Franklin

Self - Michael's sister

Michael Anthony Keough

Detective Brandon Davenport

Vincent Scott

Self - Attorney

Brandon Davenport

Self - Indiana state police detective

Ken Maxwell

Self - FBI Agent

Peter Kenny

Self - Natalia's Attorney

Liza Wolf

Melanie Miles

Elva Reyes

Self - Natalia's playmates' mother

Joseph Bellflower

Self

Jayne Parker

Self - Jury foreperson

Michele Jackson

Self - Bernett's Attorney for re-aging Natalia

Angelo Robles

Self - Family friend

Christopher Michael

Self - Former trader's point herdsman

Therese

Self - Elva's daughter

Andrew Rice

Self - Natalia's neighbor

Mark Hostetler

Self - Former farm manager at rader's point

Dwayne Farris

Self - Natalia's prospective adoptive father

Amy Simon

Neighbor

Timothy Gossweiler

Self - Natalia's Mother

Genesis Mans

Self

Halland Chen

Self - Age Specialist

Robert Goldsmith

Self - Tippecanoe Sherriff

Ryan Smith

Self - Founder and VP of Trudiagnostic

Travis Dowell

Self - Lieutenant Detective Tippecanoe SO

Eric Evangelista

Self - Executive Producer

Tamara Lee

Self - First Lady One Way Pentecostal Apostolic Church

Robert Madwell

Self

Melissa Misegadis

Self - Rehabilitation psychologist & Foster Care Director

Anna Newlin

Self

Matthew Newlin

Self - Anna Newlin's Ex-Husband