Stars (in credits order)
Jason Hawes
Self - Lead Investigator
Steve Gonsalves
Dave Tango
Self - Investigator
Shari DeBenedetti
Satori Hawes
Self - Guest Investigator, Jason's Daughter
Cody Ray Desbiens
Self - Local Paranormal Investigator
Chris Balassone
Erin Slabonik
Self - Former HSH Campus Employee
Angela Artuso
Matthew Vincent Kenny
Self - Historic Preservationist
Alissa Caridi
Stacey Costantino
Self - Assistant Librarian
Kirsten Ibe
Self - Hudson Sports Complex Manager
Raluca Gold-Fuchs
Self - Hudson Sports Complex Owner
Bill Bean
Self - Deliverance Minister
Brigid Goode
Ted Van Son Jr.
Mike Priest
Mark Walsh
Yari Ramos
Doug Hogate Jr.
Judy Kemme
Tj Cantwell
Self - Fanboy Emcee
Dave Spinks
Lee Allen
Frank Lazzaro
Patty Blatt
Ginger Wright
Self - Homeowner
Jessica Clevinger
Grace Barron
Jackie Ramos
Anissa Jones
Chuck Johnson
Chris Iannuzzi
Rick Prewitt
Self - Paradelphia Podcast Host
Kris Higgins
Jonathan Mangiante
Bruce Tango
Nicholas Croce
Self - Researcher
Darcy Brame
Mike Fraysse
Self - Burn Brae Mansion Owner
Sophia Wescott
Self - Owner, ZONE13 Tattoo
Denise Carey Bettencourt
Adam Powell
Patricia Kibby
Glenda Farquhar
Kent Vickery
Brett McGinnis
John Curley
Lauren Etheridge
Self - Property Owner's Daughter
Thomas Kelly
Donna D. Holaday
Self - Mayor of Newburyport, MA
Tom Daniels
Mario Cerrito
Chris Di Vincenzo
Jade McGuire
Self - John's Fiancé
Donna Morris
Self - Chuck's Cousin
Jenny Ferguson
Self - Grace's Mother
Brittany Totherow
Jim Higgins
Lauren Martin
Self - Christopher's Girlfriend
David Torrey de Frescheville
Self - Tenant
Janelle Mangiante
Beth Coletti
Self - Shop Owner
Jim Watson
Self - Kent Vickery's Friend
Will Burton
Chris Bettencourt
Andy Russ
Self - Mike's Son-in-Law
Jona Powell
Ana De Santis
Self - Factory Owner
Cathy Zavorskas
Self - President, Matawan Historical Society
Dale Wescott
Steve Banasick
Samantha Hawes
Jon Roth
Self - Property Owner
Dean Masajada
Johnna Kelly
Frank Flanegin
Self - General Manager
Laura Wolfe
Self - Business Owner
Jesse Wagner
Charmaine Cerrito
Grant McGuigan
Self - Project Manager
Heather Brough
Self - Josh's Wife
Sarah Blair
Self - Historian
Sara Jane Overstreet
Self - Brown House Genealogical Society
Cory Totherow
Kaitlyn Shorter
Self - Frederick Historian
John Jones
Self - Homeowner's Son
Barbara Kone
Self - Town Historian
Amy Bruni
Self - Guest Investigator
Haily Hawes
Self - Investigator, Jason's Daughter
Kurtis Roinestad
Self - Treasurer, Matawan Historical Society
Susan Russ
Self - Mike's Daughter
Christian Fuchs
Self - Professional Soccer Player
Anthony De Santis
Diana Ross McCain
Dan Carpenter
Owen Cardwell
Self - Professor, University of Lynchburg
Shaun O'Connor
Melissa Wagner
Bonny Jones
Self - Front Desk Manager
Julie Masajada
Jason Caleb Scott
Self - Water Dowsing Expert
Lori Lyn Price
Self - Local Historian
John Kinnaird
Self - Mayor of Thurmont
Summer Cerrito
Self
Scott Gilbert
Self - Civil War Historian
Dale Snapp
Nicholas Coll
Self - Library Assistant
Josh Higgins
Self - Homeowners' Son
Christina Owners Knapp
Self - Sketch Artist
Dale Perry
Self - Former Homeowner
Adam Berry
Jonathan Haug
Self - Producer
Joshua Balz
Self - Antiques Expert
Jeff Fertich
Self - Structural Engineer
Catherine Linton
Self - Collections Manager
Carol Whitmer
Al Savolaine
Kay Vickery
Self - Homeowner's Mother
John Barney
Self - Parishioner
Marion Kain
Self - Local Resident
Danielle Carpenter
Nancy Heuser
Self - Former HSH Patient
Sue King
Byron Lane
Self - City Councillor
Angel Vaow
Self - Ruth's Granddaughter
Evelyn Libengood
Self - Neighbor
Jill Vovakes
Lauren Connolly
Self - Dorothy's Family Member
Randy La Rosa
Carl Alexander
Self - Bloodhound Search and Rescue
Barbara Bass
Self - Halifax County Historical Society President
Richard Gerhardt
Self - Store Owner
Dustin Pari
Beverly Mills
Self - Co-Author, 'If These Stones Could Talk'
Joel Benedict
Self - Former Prison Guard
Chuck Wooters
Self - Search and Rescue Dogs of Pennsylvania
Karen Campbell
Self - Historian & Former Librarian
Pat Walker
Self - Former Resident
John Lender
Self - Former HSH Paramedic
Ron Mattocks
Self - Crawford County Historian
Floyd Hicks
Self - Ramapough Lenape Nation
Barry Thompson
Self - Historical Architect
Judy Miracle
Self - Historical Society President
Mark Hopkins
Self - Chief, Greater Philadelphia Search And Rescue
Elaine Buck
Milton Cook
Vicki Wooters
Chris Terrance
Self - Native American Researcher
Steve Gimpel
Self - Ellis Collins's Great-Grandson
Kachelle Steigerwald
Apparition (stairs (uncredited)
Jerry Burkhead
Ritual participant (uncredited)
Laura Rodriguez
Female homeowner (uncredited)
Hunter Burkhead
Madam Della
Witch- Ritual Spellcaster (uncredited)
Debbie Dodson
Dennis Miller Jr.