Stars (in credits order)
Ana Markova
Betsy Bell
John Ceallach
Self - Lead investigator
Newton
Self - Service Dog
Chad Higginbotham
Self - Investigator
Pat Fitzhugh
Expert
Nick White
Self - Paranormal Investigator
John Zaffis
Self - Demonologist
Beth Barnes
Sarah (2016)
Charlie Titus
Richard Bell
Robert Bell
Self - relative
Matt Gulbranson
Mayor
Aaron Latta-Morissette
Drewry Bell's Friend
Johnny Daly
Bob Bell Sr.
Marc Goodman
Preacher (2016)
John Wells
Frederick Batts (2016)
Susannah Wells
Lucy Bell (2016)
Sharlyn Sparks
Townswoman (2016)
Sonia Debreczeni
Kate Batts the Bell Witch