Evil Lives Here (2016) | Full Cast

Phoebe Kwong

DIRECTOR

Joel Pincosy

DIRECTOR

J. Tom Pogue

DIRECTOR

Colin Herlihy

DIRECTOR

Justin Lee Stanley

DIRECTOR

Bryan C. Marsh

DIRECTOR

Meaghan Cleary

DIRECTOR

Frank Di Napoli

Adult John White

James M. Reilly

Adult Dustin

T.J. Craig

Josh

Robert Levey II

Corey Breininger

Kathy-Ann Hart

Intake Nurse

John Cerny

Police Officer

Brian Vadim

Bill

David Wenzel

Det Broderick

Marian Murray

Angela Parsons Kreider (Alec's Mom)

Mark Lehneman

Co-worker

Steve Schroko

Grandfather

Jennifer Capri

Mrs. Bass

Laura Cornachio

Sara

Andrew Colford

Peter Tobin

Hillary Hamilton

Candace Sims

Margaret Keller

Self - Paul Keller's Mother

George Keller

Self - Paul Keller's Father

James Zeiss

Detective

Ava Briglia

Lindsay Wrinkles - Young Lindsay

Tim Rerucha

Eric Wrinkles

Adeleen Rosner

Lindsey Wrinkles

Amaya Press

Little Sister Ryan (2017)

Thom Bierdz

Self - Brother of Troy Bierdz

Molly Gazay

Jennifer

Kyle Merker

Doctor

Vaden Thurgood

Christian Fuhr

Sawyer Ploski

John Duck (Teen)

William W. Wallace

Aaron Christopher Foust

James Francis Kellinger

Corrections Officer

Vincent Rabil

Self - Assistant District Attorney

Cindy Taylor

Self - Blanche Taylor Moore's Daughter

Hannah Brahney

Rachels Daughter

J. Michael Baran

Doctor

Laura Rothschild

Diner Patron

Brooke Turner

Swinger Wife

Mark Montalbano

FBI Agent

Adam Aminov

Young Doug

Benjamin Oduro

Guard

Laurie Kirk

Detective

Nora Maher

Estella Sexton

Megan Han Lee

Bartender

Lauren Orlando

Debrah

Melissa Sutkowski

Clare Bradburn

John Shepard

George Yazguirre

Jack St. Pierre

Young Jack

Griffin Wallace Henkel

Ron's friend

Christian Carrigan

Michael

Trevor Lyons

Andrew Stawicki

Katherine Leidlein

April

Michael Formoso

Young BJ Beebe

River Mason Eromosele

Kabib son

Malcolm A. Chavis

Karim

Michael Stephen Walls

Alan

P.J. Bracco

Cabbie

Lenny Grossman

Cristobel Palacio

Isaac J. Conner

Jon Eason

Leslie Bacon

Cheri Tate

Dannah Basgall

May

Soulo Smith

Elder Thomas

Aaralyn Anderson

Theresa Feury

Luka Danilovich

Son

Bob Gallagher

Attorney

Kali Veronica

Laura Castillo

Victoria Joliddie

Morgan's Daughter

Jordyn Lauria

Jessica

Carrie Charlesworth

CPS Worker

Joel Isaac

Doctor

Nick Scott

Joe

Michael Muñiz

Bar Patron

Max MacKenzie

Brian Britton

Susan Hamlin

Self

Lindsay Wrinkles

Self - Eric Wrinkles Daughter

Khouri St.Surin

Vaughn

Dane West

Gabriel Campos

Estephania LeBaron

Self - Ervil LeBaron's Daughter

Ross Kugman

Johnny

Louis Jannuzzi III

Bobby Long (teen)

Gian Shines

Harassing guy

Alexander Pennecke

Bernard Eugene Giles

Anna Fikhman

Karen Kuzma

Blair Ribero

Nurse

Carmella Kaiser

Child Belinda

Tyler Shore

Sheriff's Deputy

Cameron Balbi

Tyler Worley

Jennifer Hamlin

Self (Susan's daughter)

Jayani Jalese

Jill Garrison

Andrew Spieker

Brian

George Hider

John Wayne Gacy

Clare Hamlin

Self (Susan's daughter)

Lamar K. Cheston

Nathaniel White

Ian Zelbo

Young Jamie

Lacey Caroline

Kendra

Sage Buchalter

Amy

Michael Pate

Paul Winter

Alec Hamlin

Self (Susan's son)

Kristen Doscher

Hitchhiker

Nicholas Harney

Jamie's Ex Husband

Mikhail Latham

Amy's friend

Asen Grigorov

Detective

Natalie Roy

Kathy Johnson

Emmy James

Cathy Wilson

Alexandra Rose Krieger

Beth Cruz

Marc Chouen

Brian Sugrim

Josh Rhett Noble

Keith Johnson

Sean Pohle

Robbie Hawkins

Liz Galalis

Alice Lundgren

Erin Wheelock

Richard's Girlfriend

Stephen W. Tenner

Jim Cruz

Devan Clark

Danyall White

Amanda Joy Loth

Bernadette Sugrim

Lindsay Becker

Young Danyall White

Nikki Lowe

Sheila Cruz

Michael Kelberg

Ronald Hawkins

Candace Sims

Self - Robbie Hawkin's Step-Mother

Scott Rocco

Police Officer

Cathy Wilson

Self - Peter Tobin's Ex-Wife

Eric Jennings

Richard Paul White

Gabe Milligan-Green

Kevin Currie

Douglas A. Robbs

Asylum Patient

Bernadette Hyde

Self - Brian Sugrim's Wife

Ron Andolsek

Self - Kirtland OH Police Department (ret.)

Mark Mucci

The Minder

David Cantor

School Principal

John Elefantis

Detective

Marc Wooters

Jeffrey Lundgren

Sydney S Matthews

Suzy Luff

Ron Hawkins

Self - Robbie Hawkin's Father

Jessica McHugh

Jenny Janutolo

Keith Johnson

Follower of Jeff Lundgren

Kevin Currie

Follower of Jeff Lundgren

Lily Brooks O'Briant

Jennifer Hamlin

Oryan Landa

State trooper

Grayson Eddey

Young Ben Keller

Maeve Press

Wallace Jeff's Daughter

Anthony Misiano

James Thimm

Helen Laser

Kate

David Paul

Police Officer

Noelle Hogan

Carly

Laura Frenzer

Marie Witte

Tiffany Hall

Self

Donny Ness

Young Eric Witte

Kristin Samuelson

CPA Agent

Cortney Gift

Alice Choyce

Ayla Schwartz

Tiffany's Friend

Jessica Cherniak

Young Tiffany Shore

Sherry Shafer

Self - Brian Britton's Sister

Lexie LaPlante

Teen Tiffany

James DeFilippi

Young Brian

Owen Dammacco

Young Jason

Kayciblu Wright

Young Crystal Choyce

Bill Mellen

Detective Mittelstaedt

Ed Bergtold

Anthony Allen Shore

Scott Churchson

Tim Brownstone

Christine J. Carlson

Susan Hamlin

Adison Eisenberg

Clare Hamlin

Wallace Jeffs

Self - Warren Jeff's Half Brother

Michael Buoni

Wallace Jeffs (adult)

Shannon Krowicki

Aunt Natalie

Marian Edmiston

Aunt Jenny

Nate Steinwachs

Warren Jeffs

Dallin Shea Halls

Brent Jeffs

Santiago Mallan

Teen Wallace Jeffs

Hayden Oliver

Teen Paul Keller

Maddox Elliot

Young Dennis Ryan

Beth Woodruff

Sherry

Micah Chartrand

Paul Keller

Jerry Topitzer

Dennis Britton

Crystal Choyce

Self (Alice & William's daughter)

Colleen Gilbert

Jehovah's Witness

Maria Wolf

Margaret Keller

Marta Kotzian

Debbie Wrinkles

Devin Hatch

Teen Warren Jeffs

Linda Lewis

Self (Patrick's mother)

Levi Penley

Adult Sean

Alice Swafford

Self (William Choyce's ex-wife)

Neely Johnson

Wife

Christopher Pickhardt

Paul Witte

Dianne Rothenberg

Mom

Charles Mittelstaedt

Self - Chief of Detectives, Poughkeepsie NY Police Department

Claire McClanahan

Mother Ryan

Kaitlin Campbell

Young Sherry

Matthew Trygar

Teen Dennis Ryan

Maxwell Wesslock

Young Butch

Kevin Molduene

Mark Hamlin

Sean Lewis

Self (Patrick's brother)

Antoine Hall

Sister's Boyfriend

Tiani Wright

Teen Crystal Choyce

Adam Cantor

Ryan Hamlin

Maggie Hollinbeck

Tiffany's Aunt

Melissa Moore

Self - Keith Jesperson's Daughter

Sheila Ball

Bobby's Mom

Skyler Elyse Philpot

Younger Brooke

Elizabeth Vermilyea

Cindy Long

Bernice Wallace

Diane CPS Agent

Rob Moretti

Kevin Dunlap

Sophie Sörensen

Shelly Lietz

George Zouvelos

John Armed Detective

Luz Ozuna

Rachel

Nicholas Corda

Greg Bierdz

Kathryn Mayer

Johnny's Girlfriend

Jason Collett

Heber

Valerie Logan

Doctor

Aaron Smallwood Jr.

Young Reggie

Eva J.M. Smith

Cindy's Friend (Teen Girl 1)

Andrew Burdette

Brother

Scott Watson

Bobby Long

Terry Jo Howard

Self - James Randall's Ex-Wife

Alana Barrett-Adkins

Vernetta Ellerbee

Casey Marie Ecker

Teen Cindy

Michael Corleone Blanco

Self - Griselda's Blanco's Son

Gillian Todd

Debra Davis

Vincent Yacovelli

Sexton Child

Leonydus Johnson

Detective

Alex Cioffi

Johnny

Robert James Hickey

Grandfather

Tyler Williamson

Chris

Elizabeth Bluhm

Bully Girl 1

Mikayla Petrilla

Teen Betty

Jordan Coates

Young Troy

Oriah Elgrabli

Young Linda

Andrew G. Black

Father

Patricia Lawrence

Grandmother

Kevin Francis Brodie

Officer Johnson

Selima Smith-Dell

Young Beverly

Steve Lichtenstein

Mr. Andrews

Nana Ponceleon

Mother

Noah Forrest

Detective

GinaMaria Delio

Teen Ulayla

Kelly Mulvihill

Teenage girl

Justin Nelson

Willie Sexton

Jill Garrison

Self - Nathaniel White's Ex-Girlfriend

Dennis Matos

Joe Brewster

Donalia Jones

Jill's Cousin

Bryden Elliott DiGennaro

Scott

Jesse S. Martin

Officer Hogan

Dexter Strong

Robert Rhodes

Stephan F Feeley

Detective

Brittini Schreiber

Kathy

Logan Raposo

Officer Barry

Roslyn Seale

Beverly

Mucho Garcia

Clint's Friend

Brittany Shaffer

Teen Melissa

Kasey Murray

Bobby Joe Long

Lukas Max

Troy Bierdz

Bryan C. Marsh

Uncle Kevin

Lauren Carter Reilly

Pixie Sexton

Linda Scarpa

Self - Gregory Scarpa's Daughter

Gregory Barker

Swingers club Patron

Graceann Dorse

Rose Jesperson

Kylie Silverstein

Estephania LeBaron - Preteen

Vincent Sistrunk

Police Officer

Al Dubinsky

Police Officer

Hany Osman

Elliot Rivera

Cindy Brown

Self

Ta'j

Young Vaughn

Claudia Sersanti

Blanche

Jason Eric Ross

Keith Jesperson

Sophia Guarnaschelli

Young Sherry

Rich Gentilcore

Detective 2

Vongai Shava

Student

Cody M. Marsh

Young Johnny

Alex Apgar

Young Charles

Omar Pelaez

Mario

Natalie Rosati

LeBaron Child

Zach Catanzaro

Teen Derek

Phoenix Higgins

Richard Ellerbe

Nicole Cano

Yolanda

Vernetta Cockerham

Self - Richard Ellerbee's Widow

Hugo Salazar Jr.

Scarpa Driver

Cynthia Shaw

Mother

Brooke Lehman

Self - Kevin Dunlap's Ex-Wife

Kent R. Williams

Roy

Walt Chavis

Self - Clay Smith's Brother

Jennifer Schmidt Ferreira

Griselda Blanco

Elizabeth Everett

Phyllis

Adrian Valle Torres

Brother

Courtney Jacoby

Misty Erwin

Henry Storrs

Doctor

Ruth Rocky

Bar Patron

Nicole Ketchledge

Estephania LeBaron - Teen Years

Ned Pryce

Charles Sexton

Madison Mcfarlane

Older Lauren

Siena Corrigan

Melissa's daughter

Mitchell Savitsky

12 year old Troy

Callahan Fore

William Sexton

Maurice Little

Older Reggie

Tiffany Iris

Maisel

Alyssa Maria App

Daughter

Thomas Cambridge

Eddie Lee Sexton

Jeremy Bar-Illan

Leo

Jenny Rodriguez

Search party member

Harley Yeager

Teen Dean

Sally Connors

Mama

Rebecca Ross Bailey

Betty

Jacqui Denski

Teacher

Kaitlyn Schieble

Young Betty

Colette Gabrielle

Swinger Wife

Jaylen Howe

Young Richard Ellerbee

Justin Pontier

Arthur

Ronda Swindell

Mrs. Ellerbee

Adam Link

Detective

Linda Wittmier

Self - James Randall's Ex-Wife

Marie Lenzi

Public Defender

Castor Feinberg

Middle Melissa

Mia-Jeanne Frattino

Adult Linda

Art Daudelin

Leo Dell

David Michael McMillan

Detective Crumby

Valentin Montero

Deputy

Nina Bogosian

Teen Vanessa

Alanna Stein

Middle Sister

Lucy Shelby

Ulayla

Brett Singer

DA

Tommy Dodd

Swinger Club Member

Zach Abraham

Teacher

Chengusoyane Kargbo

Teen Candice

Lewis Perez

Officer Henderson

Scott Manginelli

Police Officer

Anthony LeDonne

Deputy Johnson

Casey Nadzam

Older Brooke

Anthony Duluc

Barfly

Stephanie Lehman

Self - Kevin Dunlap's Daughter

Brent Tuccillo

Charlie

Rich Masotti

ACTOR

Alexandra Mesaros

Teen Melissa

Jon Martens

Boy

Josh Dye

Bob

Alex Cerdeira

Teen Jamie

Mike Connell

James Taylor

JR Carter

Jill's Brother

Erin Shaughnessy

Sister #2

Jerico Bleu

Teen BJ

M. LaVora Perry

Older Beverly

Beverly Brooks

Self - Reginald Brook's Ex-Wife

James Malcom

Groom

Emily Jean Ferry

Daughter 2

Karen Williams

Self - Richard Ellerbee's Sister

Jacob Levenstien

Derek

Darren Difalco

Police Officer

Drew DeSimone

Thom Bierdz

Natasha Gleichmann

Stephanie Dunlap

Jasmine Ward

Teen Karen

Rob Tromp

Uncle Albert

Avital Hermann

Young Cindy

Jacqueline Kiang

Student

Frank Provenzano

Linda's Husband

Jack Malykin

Police Officer

Sherrell-Oliver Riley

Funeral Goer

Nathan Oesterle

Dean

Greg Mays

Detective 1

Kalie Swann

Young Pixie

Ta-Tanishia Pearson

Ms. Spencer

Carlos Silva

Swinger Club Member

Garrett Swann

Young Son

Keeley Karsten

Child Pam Sinclair

Melanie Little

Older Cindy

Wesley Holloway

Jason

Taylor Henderson

Young Norma Hawkins

Mark Dancewicz

Ron

Lilliana Ketchman

Robin Lindsay

Kailey Merida

Older Teenage Sister

Josiah Schneider

Teen James

Mason Cufari

Roberta's son

Katelyn Sparks

Pamela Sinclair

Michael DeBarge

Prison Inmate

Steven Thomas Gamble

Police Officer

Karen Kuzma

Self - Sister

Billy Brannigan

Lawrence Harris

Rachel Oremland

Teen Elizabeth

Donna Glaesener

Youth Administrator

Taylor Scott

Marla Kreuger

Dominic DiGravio

Alec Kreider

Kelley Lord

Tonya

Bryn Berg

Willa Jean

Carl Burrows

Paw Paw

Malinda Logan

Felecia Collier

Jake Murphy

Teen Brother

Steve Garfanti

Detective #2

Leah Janvier

Tattletale Sister

Jordan Allen Bell

Adult Ian Stawicki

Frank Volpe

Amy's Friend

Matthew Chizever

Ed Graf

James Edward Holley

Bob Swanson

Madeline Hoarle

Young Elizabeth

Alphonso Walker Jr.

Aswad Ayinde

Richard Chandler

Bar Patron

Jamie Ragusa

Mama Giles

Rachel Gold

Louise Turpin

Brianna Hauser

Young Sheila

Dave Shaver

Police Officer

Roberta Thompson

Shirley Allen

Regina Gibson

Kathy's Sister

Elizabeth Flores

Self - Louise Turpin's Sister

James Denzer

Teen Robert

Henry Eden

Mark

Emma R. Mudd

Daycare girl

Emily Olcott

Brittany

Lori McLeod

Self - Scott Kimball's Ex-Wife

Gloria Holmes

Loan Officer

Mark A. Gauthier

Chester

Melissa Malone

Kaysi

Emily Nash

Teen Patty

Chrizney Roth

Kat Harris

Steven Strickland

FBI Agent

Meridith C. Grundei

Jackie Brown

Cardin Benjamin

Child Brother

Heather Hurst

Neighbor

Joan Chak

Mrs. Stawicki

Jordan Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Joanna Pinto

Clare's sister in law

Samantha G Harris

Jamie

Jaden Mcknew

Teenage Son

Ryan Umbarila

Young Joshua

Bruno Pascale

corrections officer

Louise Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's sister

Michael J. Doherty

Teen Andrew

Sheri Boughner

Self - John Wayne Gacy's Neice

William Knorr

Self - Theresa Knorr's Son

Zafina Stewart

Teenage Aziza

Rachel Eddy

Teenage Daughter

Matt Flowers

Charles Sinclair

Casey Davis

Levi

Kelly Bennett

Adult Elizabeth

Tre Turner

Paramedic #1

Shanisse Palmer

Older Aziza

Scott Broughton

Scott Kimball

Nathaniel Kent

Anthony Lord

Sabatino Cruz

Young Gene

Paul Noonan

Detective

Matt Rydzewski

Firefighter 1

Giuseppe Virzi

Young - Ian Stawicki

Henry A. Stein

Older Brother as child

Jessica McCrorie

Teen Turpin Girl

Mark D. Gersten

Restaurant Patron

John Mensah

Soldier

Sophie Maya Spencer

Friend

David Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's brother-in-law

Simone McKnew

Sister

Kevin B. Mulligan

Congregation member

Kristin Lauria

Police Officer

Jo Walker

Jamie's Aunt

Devin Murphy

Young Karen Gacy

Necole Milone

Paramedic

Danitra Faithe

Jackie's Sister

Jessica Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Clare Bradburn

Self - Ed Graf's Ex-Wife

Joseph Sean Murphy

Ronald Giles

Vanessa McMahan

Younger Cindy

Justy Kosek

Teen Brother

Steve Machita

Police Officer

Aaliyah

Clyburn

Jeanetta Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Andrew H. Rosenbloom

Younger brother

Joey Gregoire

Young Michael

Aziza Kibibi

Self

Remington Ford

Young Gwen

Messalina Morley

Neighbor 2

Tim Kreider

Self - Alec's Father

William Bracker

Walter Stawicki

Tracey Evans

Counselor

Walter Stawicki

Self - Ian's Father

Cooper Carrell

Ronald

Annee Agnello

Ruby Grace

Samantha Wendorf

Nurse

Ayanna Hutson

Chester Girlfriend

Tom Wendling

Lloyd

Aliya Victoriya

Norma Hawkins

David Segarra

Younger Karl

Tiffany Mulan

Alyssa's Sister

James Henslee

Self - Junior Lee Beebe's cousin

Diane Cohen

Mrs. Gacy

Vera Kelman

Louise Turpin

Michelle A. Fuller

CSI Tech

Julissa Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Michael Murphy

Neighborhood

Frank Russo

Diner Patron

Tracey Remarais

Nurse

Felecia Collier

Self - Chester Turner's Ex-Girlfriend

James Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's nephew

Maurice Carlton

Daddy

Joy Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

BobAndrew Speirs

First Husband of Shirley Allen

Taryn Grey

Mrs. Stawicki

Ivy Bella Fischer

Young Patty

Rich Henkels

Detective #1

Jamie Clark

Anthony Lord's Ex-Girlfriend

Joanna Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Jennifer Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Eric Novak

Younger Walter Stawicki

Dawn L. Stanley

Diner Patron

Johanna Lugo

Clare's Friend

Katrina Tutschek

Teen Guenevere

Joshua Hudnall

Self - William's Son

George Walsh

Older Karl

Charles Manning

David Turpin

Frank Osso

Charlie

Norma Hawkins

Self - Shirley Allen's Daughter

Kat Harris

Self - Lawrence Harris' Sister

William Hudnall

Self - Joshua's Father

Julianne Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Daniella Wallace

Felicia Daughter

Jonathan Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's nephew

Jackie Brown

Self

Salvatore Cali

Courtroom Gallery

Alain Laforest

Private Investigator

Brian Chandler Cook

Joshua Hudnall

Jolinda Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece

Alan Sewell

Neurosurgeon

Kimberly Edwards

Mom

Joshua Turpin

Self - Elizabeth Flores's nephew

Evelyn Sabbag

Cindy's Aunt

D. Scott Johnson

Police Officer #2

Jaide Fisher

Teen brother

Jennifer Bird Pownall

Bar Patron

Jackie Hill

Bar Patron

Olarinde Esuola

Police Officer Garland

Philip Di Maria

Paramedic

Anthony Cippola

Justin

Marla Krueger

Self - Lawrence Harris' Ex-Wife

Sage May

Joy's Friend 2

Dwayne R Grant

Intruder

Greg Nutcher

Howard Willis

Nathan Clarkson

John

John Morgan

Jody

Marlon Quijije

Richard Girgis

Alessandra Rosenfeld

Young Sister

Laurie Hamfeldt Mahoney

Judith Hawkey

Shirley Gaskins

Self - Donald 'Pee Wee' Gaskins' Daughter

Lindsey Bryce

Terra Newell

David Schifter

Peewee Gaskins

Corey Breininger

Self - Judith's stepson

Samantha Zaino

Teen Sister

Eli Cox

Biker Buddy

Ariane M. Reinhart

Betty Lou Beets

Liz Days

Ariet Girgis

Philip Trossarello

Robert Hawkey

Amanda Tenen

Girlfriend

Jack Stone

Kevin Duck (teen)

Brett Solimine

Det. Barstill

Robyn Babina

Mom

Greg Bergman

Detective OReilly

Ben Dawson

Robert Howard Bruce

Michael Carr

Robert Foust

Tony Brown

Mothers Boyfriend

Isabelle Ballard

Kim Ghelkins

Rebekah Madebach

Female Intruder

Tim Stainrod

Police Officer

Debra Newell

Self

Michelle Rae

Vickie Webb

Alex Schecter

Johnny Knight

Shannon Mann

Michele Ward

Kat Lindsay

Joylynn Martinez

Alina Cecilia

Judith's daughter

Seth Leighton Hale

Jack Owen Spillman

Caroline J Cassidy

Young Gina

Alex Mestre

Jolene's son

Joylynn Martinez

Self - Robert Howard Bruce's Ex-Wife

Julia Beach

Wilda Ellis

Ryan Girgis

Self - Magdi Girgis' Son

Michele Ward

Self - Richard Daniel Starrett's Ex-Wife

Olivia Vessel

June

Carmine Giordano

Cop #2

Terra Newell

Self - Debra Newell's Daughter

Nicholas Thomas

Strange Man

Jasper Burger

Young Roy

Spencer Dunn

Tim's Friend

Kathleen Boddington

Debra Newell

Scott Morrell

School principal

Robert Howard Bruce

Self - Robert Howard Bruce

Suzanne Armstrong

FBI Chief

Travis Spencer

Self - Timothy Wilson Spencer's Brother

Richard Girgis

Self - Magdi Girgis' Son

Wendy Heagy

Doctor

Peyton Gifis

Young April

John Duck

Self - Kevin's Brother

Carleigh Johnston

Roy's Niece

Kacey Bair

Joy's Friend

Emily Peragine

Ashton

Travis Kerr

Donald Gaskins

Felipe Caita

Ryan Girgis

Ramsey K. Heitmann

Jonh Duck

Adam Files

Ronnie

Gina Malone

Self - Timothy Bass' Ex-Wife

Brooke Rochman

Self - Voice Over Talent

Christina Hildreth

Self - Survivor

Robert Foust

Self - Aaron Foust's Father

Lily Anna Schechter

Young Shirley

Andrew N Sears

Patrick Alexander (child)

Deborah Tighe

Suzanne Kipper

Michelle Principi

Roy's Girlfriend

Emmanuel Awe

Tim's Friend

Lily Donahue

Amber

Steve Strom

Principal

Alex Joseph Theis

Teen Aaron

Colleen McGloin

Mother in law

Jackson Davis

Young Bass

Shirley Furgala

Self - Betty Lou Beets' Daughter

Pat MacDonald

Adult Kevin

Robin Healey

Self

Joyce Alexander

Self - William Partrick Alexander's Mother

Devin S. O'Brien

Cop #3

Ruth Weaver

Self - Paul Keller's Sister

Jessi Toronjo

Self - Jeffrey Pelley's Stepsister

Andrew Terranova

Young Ryan

Tim Halvorsen

Jeff Pelley

May Sullivan

Self - Roy Spillman's Sister

Taylor Woolever

Young May

Malachi Peters

Bass Webb

Teri Knight

Self - Manuel Gehring's Ex-Wife

Ron Powell

Intruder #2

Roxy Arecco

Adult Sister

Richard Rouse

Self - Pastor, Trinity Lutheran Church

April Steele

Self - Roy Spillman's Sister

Jonathan Ridore

Young Travis

Liz Burdick

Grandmother

Ben Keller

Self - Paul Keller's Brother

Vickie Webb

Self - Bass Webb's Mother

Wilda Gadd

Self - Howard Hawk Willis' Ex-Wife

Josh Bernard-Kriegl

Walter Neeley

Charlotte Fountain-Jardim

Sister

Ethan Mathias

Young Daniel

Alanna Smith

Belinda

Anthony Carvello

Peter Avsenew

Sam Duncan

Child Matt

Tim Shelburne

Robert Walden

Felice Kakaletris

Emma 2021

Indiana Arnold

Daniel's Brother, Neighbor Bitten by Dog

Nikki Neurohr

Sharon Morris

Javan Nelson

Robert Brasher

Cecilia Kurachi Ubé

Cathy Mills

Hudson Barry

Peter

Kike Ayodeji

Patrick's Sister-In-Law

Rocco Palmieri

Matt Roth

Natasha Walfall

Wife

Richard Bird

Dad

Francesca Rain

Young sister to Camellia Brown

Ricky Lewis

Detective Gleeson

Michael Ignatow

Self - Melvin Ignatow's Son

Lauren Pisano

Mom

Mia Fowler

Teshana

Daniel Alatorre

Young Cristobal

Kelly Pletcher

Self - Wayne Adam Ford's Ex-Wife

Cely Riva

Patrick's Ex

Cathy Mills

Self - Robert Walden's Ex-Wife

Jocelyne O'Toole

Waitress

Drew Levy

Teen Mike

Jacqueline O'Kelly

Rose Marie Brashers

Cindy Blust

Self - Camellia Brown's Sister

Kyle Dunn

Eric

Sandra Marante

Christina Gaines

Daniel Williams

Cedric

Matt Roth

Self - Kenneth Roth's Adopted Son

Yael Fern

Adult Cindy

Oliver Comstock Reynolds

Darren Sykes

Daniel Rolle

Self - Donald Rolle's Son

Ammie Turos

Self - Christian Fuhr's Ex-Girlfriend

Stacy Kuykendall

Self - Cameron Todd Willingham's Ex-Wife

Teshana Singleton

Self - Cedric Rick's Ex-Wife

Mike Magliocca

Wayne Adam Ford

Vincent Gruosso

Kenneth Roth

Sarah Garone

Self - Gary Hardy's Stepdaughter

Cheri Tate

Self - Edward Allen Covington's Ex-Wife

Dave Morrissey Jr.

Donald

Adam Courtney

Child Michael

Claire Throssell

Self - Ex-Wife of Darren Sykes

Julia Maggiola

Mindy

Asher Edgecliffe-Johnson

Young Peter

Valerie Saturno

Jennifer Winter

Deborah Brashers

Self - Robert Eugene Brashers' Daughter

Christina Gaines

Self - Patrick Fowler's Ex-Girlfriend

Sonja Holt

Self - Stafford Shaw's Ex-Fiancé

Jennifer Winter

Self - Cristobal Palacio's Ex-Wife

Belinda Christopher

Self - Eric Nance's Sister

Sharon Morris

Self - Anthony Fiebiger's Ex-Boyfriend

Kristian Sorensen

Adult Daniel

Kelsey Nichole Black

Claire

Robyn Barry

Self - Craig Thrift's Ex-Wife

Joe Alo

Cousin Tony

Jon Eason

Self - Dylan Eason's Father

Amber Leanne Rothberg

Teen Amy

Sharief Johnson

Greg

Emmanuel Almonte

David's Friend

Jacob Applegate

Adult David Schafer

Dupree Francois Porter

Steve

Lauren Hart

Detective

Liz Bishop

Morgan's Mom

Emma Pearson

Alice

Quinn McCarthy

Child Amy

Andrew Chan-Possemato

Young Jordyn

Brandon Keeton

CPS Worker

Theodore Dalton

ACTOR

Miranda Powers

Sandy

Garrett Taylor

Tony Alamo

Carter Meehan

Morgan's Son

Chelsea Diane

Jealous Co-Worker

Sarah Ann Leahy

Patty

Dylan LaRay

Cop

Marie-Kaniyah Porter

Young Kara

Hana Leigh

Vicki Jensen

Christon Andell

Steve's Friend

Lucas Toll Luchsinger

Benji (teen)

Katie Lewis

Adult Amy

Mark Willis

Ex-Boyfriend

Lara Fox

Benji's mother Beth

Flynn Lantz

Mark

Henry Glendon Walter V

Child David

Nathan Simpson

Chris Matechen

Rae-Shan Barclift

Mom

Alvin Christmas

Vern

Charmar Jeter

Dad

Cormac Joyce

Ernest

Sam Christie

Self - Ernest Christie's Son

Alden Walcott

Young Girl

Marika Kuzma

Mother

Kenneth Andrew

Adult Sam

Riley Robinson

ACTOR

Daniel Allitt

Young Dustin

Steven Curtis Jones

Grandfather

Kaan Akyol

Military Police

Theresa Burns

Diane

Zachary Garmers

Chadney

Laurel Brower

Sister #2

Peter Tedeschi

Mr. Woods

Melody Ladd

Alice Jenkins

Jesse Eging

Self - Mary Rowles' Son

Aaron Shuf

Young Benji

Summer Stern

Marissa

Amy Chesler

Self - Jesse Winnick's Sister