Still A Mystery (2018) | Full Cast

Benita Alexander-Noel

Narrator

Larry Mihlon

Self - Retired Police Chief

Andrew McPherson

Narrator

Karin Johnson

Self - Reporter

Matt Johnson

Self

Marc Hoover

Self - Podcaster

Amber Sitton

Self - Podcaster

Hayley Guenthner

Self - Anchor and Reporter

Mickey Hamilton

Self - Detective Thurston County SO

TJ Ward

Self - Private Investigator

Stacy Bridavsky

Self - Podcast Host

Cassie Fambro

Self - Reporter NBC15 Mobile AL

Selma Eikelenboom

Investigator

April Moore

Self - Holly's Sister

Heidi Hemmat

Self - Reporter Fox31

Ray Moore

Self - Holly's Father

Tim Ratcliff

Self - Sgt., Castle Rock CO Police Department

Etienne Maurice

Self - Lyric's Friend

Amanda Lamb

Self - Crime Reporter

Doug McHenry

Self - Lyric's Dad

Pam Dearwester

Self - Jason's Mother

Mike Ballard

Self - Crystal's Uncle

Fallon Glick

Self - Reporter, WDRB

Kim Turnquist

Self - Julia's Mom

Rick McCubbin

Self - Fmr. Chief, Bardstown KY Police Department

Tim Covil

Self - Investigator

Leslie McAllister

Self - Taylor's Morther

Mike Belanger

Self - Steven's Family Lawyer

Max Mayes

Self - Private Investigator

Cara Jorgensen

Self - Friend

Dan Suchan

Self - Eric's Stepfather

Dara Riordan

Self - Jennifer's Friend

Kevin Boughton

Self - Former KGUN Reporter

Madison Turnquist

Self - Julia's Sister

Carmilla Rucker

Self - Taylor's Mother

Jackie Stevens

Self - Sandra's Sistter

Brooke Bryan

Self - Crystal's Sister

Jon Haider

Self - Eric's Brother

Christa Handford

Self - Jennifer's Sister

Elfreda Tyler Anderson

Self - Keeshae's Aunt

Briana Whitney

Self - Reporter, 3TV News

Vance Patton

Self - Det., Indiana State Police

Steven Hirschfield

Self - Journalist

Thomaitsa Petru

Self - Taylor's Best Friend

Edna Sims

Self - Family Spokesman

Kevin Johnson

Self - Former Asst. Chief of Police

Stacey Talbot

Self - Inspector, Royal Canadian Mounted Police

Becca Livingston

Self - Ketie's Sister

Taylor Dial

Self - Christian's Friend

Dave Morris

Self - Sheena's Father

Tina Barrett

Self - Markham Family Attorney

Kelly Osborn

Self - Sheena's Mother

Jessica Oh

Self - Reporter, WLKY TV News

Jonathan Carlson

Self - Investigative Journalist

Chris Thompson

Self - Christian's Uncle

Kassie Coleman

Self - Disttrict Attorney, 10th Circuit Court

Maryellen Suchan

Self - Eric's Mother

Maya McHenry

Self - Lyric's Sister

Sheila Wysocki

Self - Private Investigator

Andy Howe

Self - Clay County Sheriff

Erica Kampfe

Self - Alicia's Sister

Tim Nielsen

Self - Jenna's Husband

Tom Roby

Self - Family Spokesman

Jason Kubota

Self - Jenna's Brother

Lacey Young

Self - Jason

Matt Hefner

Self - Det., Charlotte Mecklenburg NC Police Department - Cold Case Unit

Crystal Sanchez

Self - Maria's Sister-In-Law

Nicole Caan

Self

Martin Esquivel

Self - Maria's Brother

John Crews

Self - Jonathan's Father

Tim Dimoff

Self - Private Investigator

Kyle Eastridge

Self - Former Homicide Detective

Nicole Gonzalez

Self - Mark's Sister

Salvatore Rastrelli

Self - Det., Martin County FL Sheriff's Office (ret.)

Bethany Svacina

Self - Alicia's Friend

Michael Mooney

Self - Freelance Journalist

April Eve Wiberg

Self - Founding Member, Stolen Sisters & Brothers

Toni Jacobs

Self - Keeshae's Mother

Christian Crews

Self - Jonathan's Brother

Rachelle Elsiufi

Self - CityNews

Juliana Keeping

Self - Former Reporter

Ann Bowdan

Self - WKLY News

Allison Bevers

Self - Missy's Daughter

Kristi Stout

Self - Missy's Sister-in-Law

Kiersten Bragg

Self - Kiera's Mother

Joe Reynoso

Self - Mark's Father

Joe Boncucci

Self - Pinal County Homicide Detective

Sherry Ballard

Self - Crystal's Mother

Madison Shields

Self - Thomas' Friend

Kevin Blaine

Self - Jenna's Father

Tom Shaw

Self - Crew's Family Attorney

Michael Clark

Self - Det., Bardstown KY Police Department

Philip Klein

Self - Private Investigator

Toby Dagenhart

Self - Jennifer's News Director

Sylvia Stevens

Self - Sandra's Mother

Sherry Abel

Self - Jennifer's Mother

Jasmine Turner

Self - Reporter NBC12

Chris Bragg

Self - Kiera's Father

Jonathan Arden

Self - Forensic Pathologist

David Markham

Self - Katelyn's Father

Tootsie Toccaro

Self - Amber's Mother

Brendan Coffey

Self - Friend

Penny Meek

Self - Thomas' Mother

Gary Shadie

Self - Det., Akron Ohio Police Department

Braydee Bragg

Self - Kiera's Sister

Kelly Eastman

Self - Jason's Sister

Pamela Crews

Self - Jonathan's Mom

Emily Ramsey

Self - Jonathan's Friend

Katrin Steck

Self - Jennifer's Friend

Rebecca Ervin

Self - Sgt., Fairfield OH Police Department

Schyler Nielsen

Self - Jenna's Son

Bill McAllister

Self - Taylor's Father

Todd Andreacchio

Self - Christian's Father

Paul Harrop

Self - Journalist

Casey Ballard

Self - Crystal's Brother

Brandon Bevers

Self - Missy's Husband

Kip Grosenik

Self - Journalist

Alexandra Elich

Self - Reporter, WCCB

Jay'Quann Banks

Self - Taylor's Brother

Kendall Herold

Self - WCPO News

Lee Williams

Former Police Office

Stephanie Warsmith

Self - Akron Beach Journal Reporter

Jevona Livingston

Self - Ketie's Mother

Sharon Johnson

Self - Former KFYR-TV Reporter

Rae Andreacchio

Self - Christian's Mother

Janell Robinson

Self - Keeshae's Friend

Holly Moore

Self - APTN Investigates

Jennifer Niswender

Self - Julia's Twin Sister

Jan Johnson

Self - Forensic Specialist

Kris Bratten

Self - Jason's Mother-In-Law

Angeline Hartmann

Self - National Center for Missing and Exploited Children

Angenette Levy

Self - Crime Reporter

Olivia LaVoice

Self - Reporter

Travis Dorman

Self - Reporter

James Baysinger

Self - Podcaster

Carmen Asham

Self - Detective Minot Police

Michael Fleming

Self - Private Investigator

Lindy Boustedt

Self - Podcaster

Melissa Baum

Self - Lindsey's Mother

David Marshburn

Self - Private Investigator

Mary Dodson

Self - Brittany's Mother

John Sadek

Self - Andrew's Father

Theresa Hogan-Egkan

Self - Tim's Mother

Chad Piotrowski

Self - Gwendel's Brother

Peter Roach

Self - Allison's Friend

Pauline Bailey

Self - Phylicia's Mother

Erica Morse

Self - Private Investigator

Paul Ricks

Self - Leuitenant CSPD

Lori Rando

Self - Nanette's Friend

Maurice Godwin

Self - Criminal Psychologist

Tawana Spann

Self - Jabez's Mother

David Deviney

Self - Sheila's Father

Shelleymarie Magan

Self - Gwendel's Friend

Jessica Lees

Self - San Diego Deputy DA

Heather Brown

Self - Ashley's Sister

Rochelle Hopson

Self - Parris' Mother

Monty Clark

Self - Private Investigator

Peggy Brunner

Self - Desiree's Aunt

Paula Gholson

Self - Najah's Mother

Lindsay Boyle

Self - Digital Editor

DeMarcus White

Self - Dorian's Brother

Peter Berbiglia

Self - Amber's Father

Mark Burbridge

Self - Retired Police Detective

Margaret Queen

Self - Yolanda's Sister

Gary Walrath

Self - Patrick's StepFather

Yvonne Tagnani

Self - Phylicia's Cousin

Drema Skeen Allen

Self - Kayla's Mother

Issa Mansaray

Self - Africapaper Editor

Ed Lewis

Self - Reporter

Charlie Macpherson

Self - Casey's Father

Missy Canfield

Self - Susan's Sister-in-Law

Dennis Griffin

Self - Private Investigator

Jo Cameron

Self - Kala's Aunt

Randall Groetken

Firefighter

Thomas Bennett

Self - Forensic Pathologist

David Boelter

Self - Marina's Brother

Michele Drexler

Self - Allison's Sister

Linda Johnson

Self - Jessica's Mother

Clifford Johnson

Self - Detective Stockton PD

Kim Watson

Self - Nanette's Sister

Clu Wright

Self - Private Investigator

Dianne Derby

Self - Former News Anchor

Darla Gatewood

Self - Cole's Aunt

Ameera El

Self - LeRyan's Sister

Jaleesa Joseph

Self - Najah's Sister

Melinda Marmet

Self - Tommy's Sister

Ron Arnold

Self - Parris' Uncle

Michelle Paul

Self - Courtney's Aunt

Judy Fisher

Self - Family Friend

Peter Karasuk

Self - Detective Norwich PD

Aaron Saykin

Self - Former Reporter

Debanee Macpherson-Udall

Self - Casey's Sister

Sarah Fuller

Self - Rachel's Sister

Jeff Egkan

Self - Tim's Father

David Goodman

Self - Detective Sargent Minot Police

Pam Kinslow

Self - Tommy's Mother

Brian Nugent

Self - Deputy Chief of Investigations

Ervina Miller

Self - Nancy's Sister

Hanna Scott

Self - Reporter

Roe Moreno

Self - Former Police Officer

Aaron Sam

Self - Detective West Palm Beach PD

Kaitlin Durbin

Self - Former Reporter

Candace Williams

Self - LeRyan's Sister

Shawn Robinson

Self - Crystal's Boyfriend

Amanda Berbiglia

Self - Amber's Sister

Liz Wentzel

Self - Krystal's Stepsister

Faith Boelter

Self - Marina's Sister

Denise Alves

Self - Christopher's Sister

Ed Tomba

Self - Former Deputy Chief Cleveland PD

Tammy Sadek

Self - Andrew's Mother

Gairy Gibbon

Self - Desiree's Father

Jocelyn Thomas

Self - Phylicia's Sister

John O'Brien

Self - Former Reporter

Heather Ruth

Self - Hailey's Friend

Kyah Mancil

Self - Jessica's Niece

Kelly McCammon

Self - Davina's Friend

Erica Bullock

Self - Glinda's Cousin

Micheal Whelan

Self - 'Unresolved' Podcast

Tiffani Tucker

Self - Anchor

Michael Maely

Self - Reporter

David Singleton

Self - MN Civ Pub Safety Comm

Charles Robinson

Self - Detective Metro Nashville PD

Sandra Halsne

Self - Tyler's Mother

Shella Dalbey

Self - Kayla's Friend

Leigh Ann Moreno

Self - Jessica's Friend

Greg Percy

Self - Benson Police Chief

Aimee Rupel Clack

Self - Ashley's Friend

Laurah Norton

Self

David Kesseh

Self - Henry's Friend

Lee Odham

Self - Detective Sergeant

Alisha Silver

Self - Glinda's Cousin

Adam Rhew

Self - Former Editor

Woody Overton

Self - Podcaster

Mitch Drake

Self - Retired Homicide Detective

Pam Lambert

Self - Tyler's Aunt

Tanya Buff Hart

Self - Davina's Sister

Erica Smith

Self - Tyler's Sister

Corley Peel

Self - Reporter

Tatum O'brien

Self - Sadek Family Attorney

TJ Nelson

Self - KRVV TV News Anchor

Reginald Lee

Self - Brandon's Stepfather

Norman Smith

Self - Private Investigator

David Dodson

Self - Brittany's Father

Nalini Eldridge

Self - Najah's Cousin

Latohya Jakes

Self - Jabez's Aunt

Mark Richards

Self - Rachel's Step-Father

Chelsea Donovan

Self - Former Reporter

Paulette Pomeroy

Self - Casey's Mother

Michael Boelter

Self - Marina's Uncle

Areanna Gardner

Self - Dorian's Cousin

Brian Canfield

Self - Susan's Brother

Chad Noble

Self - Captain Brown County SO

Bill Moyer

Self - Nancy's Estranged Husband

John Boelter

Self - Marina's Father

Lindsay Winkley

Self - San Diego Union-Tribune

Anne Chmielewski

Self - Yolanda's Sister

Keith Smith

Self - Tyler's Father

Carol Cirioni

Self - Erika's Mother

Brooke Hargrove

Self

Susan Deviney

Self - Sheila's Mother

Chris Thomas

Self - Cole's Father

Jason Gohlike

Self - Massillon Police Detective

Yolanda Frazer

Self - Angela's Cousin

Tobbie Stover

Self - Eric's Mother

Jacob Allen

Self - Krystal's Cousin

Jan Lash

Self - Aliza's Best Friend

JD Grant

Self - Private Investigator

Carlos Muñoz

Self - Former Reporter

Sara Pagones

Self - Reporter

Craig LaBell

Self - First on Scene

Lynn Ray

Self - Courtney's Aunt

Sarah Lee

Self - Brandon's Mother

Samantha Moyer

Self - Nancy's Daughter

Rick Scott

Self - Gray's Harbor County Sheriff

Caron Chait

Self - Aliza's Neighbor and Friend

Susan Woods

Self - Family Friend

Maria Zoul

Self - Aliza's Colleague and Friend

Julie Knapp

Self - Zach's Mother

Rachel Lee

Self - Brandon's Sister

Billy Fraser

Self - Chief Investigator

Ina LaBorde

Self - Courtney's Grandmother

Taylor Bodine

Self - Karen's Daughter

Allison Joy

Self - Journalist

Darrell Mote

Self - Walker County Sheriff's Dept

Matthew Filter

Self - Detective Metro Nashville PD

Dave Fougeron

Self - Ash's Friend

Dan Watson

Self - Nanette's Father

Josephine Wentzel

Self - Krystal's Mother

Kelli Vance

Self - Zach's Friend

Michael Fleming

Self - Private Investigator

Julie Brown

Self - Ashley's Mother

Jennifer Kastner

Self - TV Reporter

Kevin Smith

Self - Tyler's Brother

Lisa Valentino

Self - Allison's Sister

Alley Bindics

Self - Yolanda's Daughter

Sarah Saari

Self - Kayla's Friend

Kimberly Gardner

Self - Dorian's Cousin

Jason Pagan

Self - Erika's Nephew

Sarah Bergman

Self - Gwendel's Friend

Christina Radcliff

Self - Gwendel's Friend

Bev Poston

Self - Nancy's Friend

Timothy Dimoff

Self - Private Investigator

Shane Stykes

Self - Brittany's Husband

Robert Eldridge

Self - Najah's Cousin

David Ballard

Self - Private Investigator

Erin Haustveit

Self - Anita's Friend

Sheila Kincaid

Self - Christopher's Aunt

Daniel Jones

Self - Tyler's Father

Marc Benson

Self - Private Investigator

Kayla Mancil

Self - Jessica's Sister

Locan Woods

Self - Parris' Cousin

Anna Knutson

Self - Anita's Sister

Clifford Knapp

Self - Zach's Stepfather

Joe Butler

Self - Jabez's Stepfather

Karlee Bodine

Self - Karen's Daughter

Katelyn Bush

Self - Yolanda's Daughter

Julie Beauchaine

Self - Kala's Cousin

Angelina Papanikolaou

Self - Desiree's Friend

Angelina Harris

Self - Najah's Niece

Judy Rust

Self - Patrick's Mother

Clint Dunn

Self - Hailey's Father

Ashley Boelter

Self - Marina's Siste-in-Law

Joseph Randall

Self - Private Investigator

Hollie Morris

Self - Susan's Best Friend

Dave Rader

Self - Texas Equusearch

Robert Talijan

Self - Gwendel's Brother

Devon Brooks

Self - Reporter

Andrea Gibbon

Self - Desiree's Mother

Stephanie Belgard

Self - Courtney's Mother

Deborah Faith

Self - MN Community Policing Svcs

George Guillory

Self - Caleb's Uncle

Jason Egkan

Self - Tim's Brother

Adrian Mojica

Self - Digital Director WZTV

Samantha Kendzior

Self - Rachel's co-worker

Kathy Thomas

Self - Cole's Mother

Kelsey Richards

Self - Rachel's Sister

Edward Czinn

Self - Aliza's Brother

Charlotte Rowell

Self - Ash's Mother

Sean Kipe

Host 'Fox Nation'

Justin Ling

Self - Journalist

Christina McDonald

Self - Christopher's Sister

Ben Dattilo

Self - Molly's Father

Michael Wells

Self - Alloura's Father

Vivianne Bernas

Self - Joseph's Sister

Rich Graham

Self - Private Investigator

Carolyn Combs

Self - Racheyl's Aunt

Keri Dattilo

Self - Molly's Cousin

Mike Campbell

Self - Reporter

Rhonda Hampton

Self - Mitrice's Mentor

Betsy Ross

Self - Private Investigator

Walter Shawn McDaniels

Self - Sargeant Richland County Sheriff's Dept

Jewel Moore

Self - Mitrice's Friend

April McGill

Self - Jessica's Friend

Simone Jameson

Self - Reporter

Milton Coleman

Self - Rhonda's Father

Matther Gurley

Self - Fellow Soldier

Steve Land

Self - Retired Police Chief

Michelle McCown Luster

Self - Niqui's Sister

Cindy Wolfe

Self - Jessica's Sister

Bryon Gibbs

Self - Shelton's Friend

Celestra Dewey

Self - Molly's Sister

Amy Coursey

Self - Host of Cold Case Chronicles

Peggy Sanders

Self - Shelton's Mother

Connie Bennett

Self - Rhonda's Cousin

Simone Jameson

Self (Reporter)

Wilveria Sanders

Self - Shelton's Sister

Tammie Hughes

Self - Niqui's Sister

Kristen Dean

Self - Racheyl's Cousin

William Sanders

Self - Shelton's Father

Jackie Smith

Self - Racheyl's Cousin

Gloria Epstein

Self - Retired Canadian Judge

Gavin Fish

Self

Michelle Wheeler

Self - Alloura's Sister

Latice Sutton

Self - Mitrice's Mother

Sarah Alva

Self - Jessica's Sister

Gayle Coleman

Self - Rhonda's Mother

Payton Lackings

Self - Niqui's Daughter

Wilbur Dattilo

Self - Molly's Brother

Minnie Bethel

Self - Niqui's Work Friend

Andrea Zaferes

Self - Aquatic Death Investigator

Joseph Smedley II

Self - Joseph's Father

Michael Richardson

Self - Mitrice's Father

Michael Arntfield

Self - Professor, Criminologist, and Author

Nic Edwards

Self - Podcaster

Lila Lazarus

Self - Former Reporter

Cory Williams

Self - Retired Police Detective

Yvonne Devries

Self - Max's Mother

Mike Hoffman

Self - Private Fire Investigator

Jason Stavers

Self - Podcaster

Erik Hiles

Self - Oakley's Foster Dad

Dominique Devries

Self - Max's Sister

Diane Maina

Self - Jane's Niece

Tammy Johnson

Self - Marshal's Mother

Pete Bass

Self - Jeff's Friend

Monica Button

Self - Nieko's Mother

Keith Eldridge

Self - Retired Reporter

Jeremy Kuria

Self - Jane's Son

Marcia Gebhardt

Self - Jeff's Mother

David Hastie

Self - Former Police Officer

Glenn Clarke

Self - Family Friend

Heather Catallo

Self - Anchor

Kerrigan Lisi

Self - Nieko's Sister

Michael Whelan

Self - Podcaster

Lewis Gebhardt

Self - Jeff's Father

Rachael Davis

Self - Nieko's Aunt

Jacquelyn Moreno

Self - Jennifer's Sister

Nathan Neese

Self - TBI Special Agent in Charge

Kassi Iwaasa

Self - Marshal's Cousin

Jason Gebhardt

Self - Jeff's Brother

Paul Logan

Self - Detective Sergeant Grey's Harbor PD

Jeannette Rocher

Self - Anchor

Jordan Karsten

Podcaster

Molly Hayes

Self - Reporter

Jamie Jo Hiles

Self - Oakley's Foster Mom

Matt Hiskes

Self - Podcaster

Cat Lee

Self - Marshal's Cousin

Leanne Thomas

Self - Laura's Mother

Anne Champion

Self - Laura's Friend

Lucy Ngugi

Self - Jane's Sister-in-Law

Charles Long

Self - Mortician

Jessica Swift

Self - Oakville Elementary Principal

Nenette Myers

Self - Jennifer's Mother

John Dawes

Self - Retired Detective

Alex Denis

Self - Anchor

Charla Perdue

Self - FSU CSI Program

Khit McVay

Self - Jennifer's Aunt

Bruce Clemonds

Self - Retired Missouri Highway Patrol

Mark Kimata

Self - Jane's Nephew