Director
Phil Morrison
DIRECTOR
Adam Bernstein
Peyton Reed
Jon Schnepp
Clay Tarver
Alex Zamm
Dana Calderwood
Stars (in credits order)
Matt Besser
Adair
Amy Poehler
Colby
Ian Roberts
Antoine
Matt Walsh
Trotter
Del Close
Narrator
H. Jon Benjamin
ACTOR
Michael Delaney
Assistant Boxing Coach
Rob Corddry
DEA Agent
Paul Scheer
Grim Reaper
Rob Riggle
Bodyguard
Billy Merritt
Angry Inmate
Horatio Sanz
Hornet Ball Victim
Alfredo De Quesada
Earthquake Partygoer
Terry Jinn
Architect
Eugene Cordero
Rob Huebel
Eli's Assistant
Katie Roberts
Delivery Room Doctor
John Ross Bowie
Cyber-Flex User
Andrew Secunda
Bailiff
Patrick McCartney
Betsy Stover
Daughter
Marc Bonnée
STUDent
Sean Conroy
Man with Binoculars
Gideon Evans
Guy with Wolfman Jack Doorbell
Randy Blair
Man in Audience
Miriam Tolan
Karen Rosco
Pat Walsh
Inmate
Chad Carter
Missy O'Reilly
Christian Fellowship Girl
Dave Blumenfeld
Doctor
Sarah Thyre
Angry Protester
Lora Lee Ecobelli
Chinese Diner
Jon Glaser
Hazmat Guy
Brian Huskey
Kevin Kenny
Earthquake Party Boy
Leo Allen
Basketball Player
Doug Sakmann
Doorframe Earthquake Partygoer
James Eason
Prison Guard
Lonny Ross
Scared Straight Student
John O. Nelson
Lifeguard
Owen Burke
Friar in the Soup
Sean Christopher Lewis
Factory Party Patron
Adam S. Barta
Museum Patron
Caroline O'Hare
Dialect Competitor
Julie Brister
Fat Anne Frank Wife
Jackie Clarke
Deaf Sister
Rob Lathan
Lab Worker
Greg Korin
Fat Refugee Priest
John Breen
Corpse
Nick Kroll
Andy Richter
Hansel
Dee Snider
Self
Tom Scharpling
Brian McCann
Crazy Businessman
Sean Harris
Vocals - Little Donny Theme Song
Adam Sietz
Gay Audience Member
James Mount
Frat Boy
Jimmy DellaValle
Frat Pledge
John Mondin
Pirate
Aaron Bergeron
College Student
Tim Washer
Ace
Nidhamu Askari
Extra
Christopher Himes
Frat Boy #1
Shannon Manning
Chef
Marian Rosin
Bathroom Lady
Julie Mullen
Prostitute
Mike Trupiano
Jesus
Trish Gray
Reset Smiths 4'10 Girlfriend
Tina Fey
Kerri Downey
Joe Lo Truglio
Airduct Friar
Andy Daly
Bathtub Friar
RZA
Bobby Digital
John Gemberling
Factory Worker
Jamie Denbo
Hooker
Seth Morris
The Real Jesus
Danielle Schneider
Spirituality Expo Patron
Liche Ariza
Ticket Scalper
Peter Stickles
SWAT Team Member
Brad Aldous
Cyborg Butler
Jake Fogelnest
Chris
John D. Bair
Roady
John Cahill
Kelsie Lynn
Ari Voukydis
John Denver Fanclub Member
Stelianie Tekmitchov
Sister Sue
Armando Díaz
Stair Person
Katty Biscone
Soup Woman
Jon Morgenthau
Japa-noi Tretching Student
Irene McGee
Jose Candelaria
Douglas Scott Sorenson
Police Officer
Vanessa Query
Kimmy the Coma Girl
Ed Zareh
Jason Mantzoukas
Orgy Man
Jessica Chaffin
Junkie Cheerleader
Eric Slovin
Husband
Dannah Feinglass Phirman
Benny's Mother
Ali Reza
Photographer
Jason Altman
Big Red Cat
Kelly Sebastian
Classmate
Mark Sarian
Dancing Lawyer
Jim Kohn
Crazy Christian Basketball Player
Mary Dimino
Nurse
Bex Schwartz
Nurse Violet
Tom Dheere
Thunderballer
Jesse Lubinsky
Award Ceremony Thug
Jonathan Weirich
Jonny Spanish
John Capo
Various
Mischa Kischkum
Doctor Diaz
Melissa Mary Ganas
Girl in Line
John W. McKelvey
David Berman
50s Football Player
Nathan Zen-Sapien
Student protester
Ben Dasaro
Home plate Umpire(uncredited)
Robert Myers
Businessman(uncredited)
Edgar Nicholson
Police Officer(uncredited)
Elliot Flament
College Student(uncredited)
David Vincent Bobb
Frat Pledge(uncredited)
Jimmy Negron
Camp kalterman kid(uncredited)
D.B. Frick
Angry Mob Member(uncredited)
Sara Barnett
Stroller(uncredited)
Regina Palian
Swinger(uncredited)
Eric Schaefer
Homeless Man #1(uncredited)