Stars (in credits order)
Michael Magid
Self
Stephen A. Smith
Self - Judge (Seasons 2, Season 3)
Kit Hoover
Judge
Grant Thompson
Contestant (Season 2 runner-up)
Whitney Scott
Contestant (Season 2, fifth eliminated)
Stuart Scott
Host
Maggie Haskins
Contestant (Season 1, third place)
Chet Anekwe
Self - Contestant (Season 1)
Zach Selwyn
Contestant (Season 1, fourth place)
Tony Kornheiser
Judge (Season 1)
Woody Paige
Judge (Seasons 2, Season 3)
LaVar Arrington
Darryl Dawkins
Contestant (Season 3, second eliminated)
Lori Rubinson
Contestant (Season 1, third eliminated)
Jason Horowitz
Contestant (Season 2, ninth eliminated)
J.R. Reid
Contestant (Season 3, third eliminated)
Dennis Scott
Contestant (Season 3, fourth eliminated)
Winston Bell
Contestant (Season 2, eighth eliminated)
K.C. James
Contestant (Season 2, third eliminated)
Nick Stevens
Contestant (Season 1, sixth eliminated)
Casey Stern
Contestant (Season 1, seventh eliminated)
Joe Voyticky
Contestant (Season 2, first eliminated)
Stephanie Rich
Contestant (Season 2, second eliminated)
Jason Ashworth
Matt Bullard
Contestant (Season 3 runner-up)
Mike Hall
Contestant (Season 1 Winner)
Alvin Williams
Contestant (Season 1, second eliminated)
Gerald Wilkins
Contestant (Season 3, first eliminated)
Chris Williams
Contestant (Season 1, first eliminated)
Kelly Milligan
Contestant (Season 1, fifth eliminated)
Al Jaffe
Michael Quigley
Contestant (Season 1, fourth eliminated)
Anish Shroff
Contestant (Season 2, tenth eliminated)
Aaron Levine
Contestant (Season 1, runner-up)
Dee Brown
Contestant (Season 3 winner)
Brian Startare
Contestant (Season 2, sixth eliminated)
Valerie Hawrylko
Contestant (Season 2, fourth eliminated)
David Holmes
Contestant (Season 2 winner)