Director
David Cargill
DIRECTOR
Gabe Torres
Brian Coughlin
Scooter Yancey
Jude Gerard Prest
Scott Corburn
Fred Peabody
Stars (in credits order)
Kathleen Garrett
Narrator
Skoti Collins
Policeman
David Hill
David Castor
Dion Graham
Self - Narrator
Kayd Currier
Detective
Aaya Lawhorn
Forensics
Trey Gowdy
Self - Solicitor of the 7th Judicial Court
Scott Crane
Detective Combs
Beth Dunton
Self - Forensics, Virginia Beach Police Department
Yeena Fisher
Debbie
Ryan Zamo
Meghans Friend
Mike Mather
Self - Investigative Reporter, WTKR
Madison Renee Elsner
Ashley
Leah Bush
Self - Chief Medical Examiner, VA
Jamie Vergan
Joseph Alfieri
Caroline Burt
Forensic Expert
Jonny Lewis
Mitchell Salberg
Detective Brennen
Melinda Bonini
Denise Corbin
Lary Crews
Stephanie's Father
Daniel Elton
Self - Investigator, Redlands Police Department
Abigail McConnell
Jennifer Myers
Rod L Harrell
Captain Steven Nigrelli
Richard Dysart
Foster Wilson
Cristina Moore
Jason Yown
Self - Spartanburg Co. Sheriff's Office
Mark Brannen
Self - Redlands Police Department
Angela B. Corey
Self - State Attorney, Florida 4th District
Reid Lindsey
Summer Malone
Student Victim
Kathleen Kingston
Self - Jacksonville Polce Department
Alan Peterson
Self - Redlands Sewer Collections Systems
Stephen Denton
Andrew Lavender
John Vindiola
Taylor Garner
Michael Ramos
Self - San Bernardino Co. District Attorney
Eddie Bounds
Self - Jacksonville Beach Police Department
Melissa Nelson
Self - Former Assistant State Attorney, Florida
Randall Emon
Self - Coroner Investigator, San Bernardino Co.
Faith Goodwin
Self - Rhonda's Mother-in-Law
William Carlyle
Betty M. Simon
Self - Tristan Jensen's Grandmother
Randy C. Hardy
Self - Spartanburg Public Safety Department
Sally Bell
Self - Tristan Jensen's Aunt
James Choate
Cathy Tessier
Self - Rhonda's Mother
Tim Petree
Self - Florida Department of Law Enforcement
Matthew Reiter
Self - Tristan Jensen's Cousin
Joey Farrell
Self - Rhonda's Brother
Paul Pinkham
Self - Reporter, Florida Time-Union
Brandon Reiter
John Barron
Self - South Carolina Law Enforcement Division
Aymee Dudley
Self - Corey Parker's Friend
Randolph Beasley
Harry Hatch
Self - San Bernardino Co. Bomb Squad
Ed Guthro
Laura Siegel
Kelly Bullwinkle
Chad T. Wood
Office Rollins
Ron Schwartz
Pastor
Lourdes Salomón Lopez
Self - Ex-Fiancée of Bradley Schwartz
Patti Prezioso
Self - Former New Jersey State Prosecutor
Jill Murphy
Self - Pima County Sheriff's Dept.
Douglas Demangone
Self - Detective, York County D.A.'s Office
Sylvia R. Lafferty
Self - Pinal County Attorney's Office
Daphne Stidham
Self - Brian Stidham's Widow
David Winston
Self - Forensic Pathologist, Pima County
Susan Dewitt
Self - Assistant State Attorney
Don Bell
Self - Salt Lake City Police Department
Kelly Anderson
Robert Dugdale
Pierre Herding
Self - Brian Stidham's Father-in-Law
Michael Umansky
Self - Alex's Brother
Brad Foust
Chris Hogan
Louis Perez
Self - FBI Agent
Ken Serrano
Self - Reporter
Kim Smith
Self - Reporter, Arizona Daily Star
Richard Platt
Jennifer Dainty
Self - Convenience Store Owner
Angel Monroe
Tiffany
M. William Phelps
Self - Author, Murder in the Heartland
Matthew Vaughan
Dana Ewell
David J Law
Detective H
William F. Bryant
Accused
Lacey Mael
Daughter
Paul Yoakam
Self - Virginia Beach Police Department
Sue Gisser
Bobbie Jo Stinnett
Christine Lozano
Detective Melinda
Dan Wells
William Fitzpatrick
Self - Onondaga Co. District Attorney
Jaccii Farris
Self - Reporter, WFMZ-TV
Mike Schnapp
Fisherman
Richard Schimmelpfenneg
Detective Mattson
Dominick Spinelli
Self - Onondaga Co. Sheriff's Department
Amber Holscher
Self - Linda's Granddaughter
Greg Baird
Catherine Dodson
Self - Senior Commonwealth's Attorney
Suzanne L. Noffsinger
Self - Miami Valley Regional Crime Lab
Chris Curtice
Self - Fresno County Sheriff's Department
Robert Egan
Self - Pennsylvania State Police
Catherine Mallet
Self - Karen's Friend
Michael Bailey
Self - Pinellas County Sheriff's Office
Rodney Baker
Self - Darke County Sheriff's Office
Lilly Smalls Gallman
Self - Forensic Scientist, SLED
Richard Ewell
Self - Dale's Brother
Kelly Ormsby
Self - 1st Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, Darke Co.
John Souza
Mike Garske
Self - King County Sheriff's Office
Hugh Murphy
George Soloman
Self - Permenter's Roomate
Kim Hudelson
Self - Linda's Daughter
Jeffery M. Owen
Self - Missouri State Highway Patrol
Randy Pannell
Self - Karen's Brother
Thien Do
Richard Danielson
Self - St. Petersburg Times
Greg Shreaves
Self - Trinity Lutheran Church
Tal English
Self - Lubbock Police Department
Uvah Roback
Self - Summer's Mother
Kenneth R. Payne
Self - Davis Co. Sheriff's Office
Melody Fairbourne
Self - Karin's Friend
Shawn Trissel
Wes Jobe
Melba Saltzgiver
Self - Karin's Stepmother
Niki Hayes
Victim
Sandra Thomas
Self - Ronald's Step-Sister
Ron Ruhman
Pam Alexander
Self - Lubbock Victims Assistant Services
Julio Mendez
William M. Mowrey
Dorothy Small
Self - Jennifer's Sister
Karolina Szamfeber
Jennifer Braun
Amber Smith
Self - Rhonda's Niece
Darren White
Self - Nodaway County Sheriff's Office
Patti Wilson
Linda Myers
Jeffrey Hammerschmidt
Self - Fresno County District Attorney's Office
Robert Willoughby
Chuck Chronopoulos
Self - Tyngsborough Police Department
Suzanne Miles
Self - Utah Bureau of Forensic Services
Nancy Marie Simpson
Self - Elise's Friend and Co-Worker
Craig Peterson
Self - Sr. Deputy Prosecutor, King County
Anna Cox
Jon Mattsen
Jim Maynard
Self - Jennifer's Brother
Kathleen Hum
Self - Center for Forensic Sciences
James Oppliger
Judy Zellner
Self - Church Member
Scott Underwood
Richard Howell
Self - Prosecuting Attorney, Drake Co.
Timothy Duerr
Don Carter
Self - Lubbock County Sheriff's Office
David Zellis
Self - 1st Assistant District Attorney, Bucks County, PA
Russell Mills
Pimp
Steven Elliott
Self - Reporter, Fresno Bee
Robert Stoppacher
Self - Onondaga Co. Medical Examiner's Office
Mark Whittaker
Craig Webb
Self - Davis Co. Attorney's Office
James Bruchak
Sue Brunner
Kevin Walsh
Jennifer Brown
Self - Gregg Myers' Former Girlfriend
Arthur Smith
Self - West Manchester Township Police Department
David Castor Jr.
Self - David Castor's Son
Ross M. Gardner
Self - Crime Scene Analyst
Elizabeth Evans
Self - York Dispatch
Clarence Montgomery
Self - Woods Cross Police Department
Ronald Lee Huston
Will E. Sanders
Self - Staff Writer, Piqua Daily Call
Mark Mills
Danny Shields
Rosemary Corbett
Self - Mike Wallace's Sister
Greg Stumpo
Antonio Menchaca
Mike Burns
Michael Holbrook
David L. Merrill
Michael Pace
Self - Witness
Joe Bill Rogers
Self - Joanna's Father
Dorothy Smith
Juanita Avitia
Self - Ewell Housekeeper
Don Engstrom
Self - Eyewitness
Rick Gregory
Self - Solicitor's Office
Carl Boman
Self - Lisa Montgomery's Ex-Husband
Wesley Shields
Jon Frank
Self - Reporter, The Virginian-Pilot
Mark Marshall
Self - Ronald's Co-Worker
Kurt Lipanovich
Self - Special Agent, FBI
Dyanne Siktar
Self - Dog Breeder
Troy Rawlings
Self - Davis County Attorney
Larry Manely
Melissa Rogers
Self - Computer Forensics, King Couny Sheriff's Office
Roger Anderson
Ben Espey
Self - Former Nodaway County Sheriff
Sridhar Natarajan
Self - Lubbock County Chief Medical Examiner
Liz Rocca
Self - Investigative Reporter, Komo News
Chelsea Lynne Veal
Self - Lisa Montgomery's Daughter
Larry Nalven
Melinda Ybarra
Coco Saltzgiver
Self - Karin's Sister
Matt Whitworth
Self - Deputy U.S. Attorney
Steve Baker
Self - Northern Bureau Chief, WHIO-TV
Roger Carter
Michael Elder
Self - Jury Foreman
Jim Kenyon
Self - Investigative Reporter, WSTM-TV
Brian Ricardo
Self - Former Special Agent, NCIS
Bryan Chapa
Self - Lubbock County Landfill Foreman
Matthew D. Powell
Self - District Attorney of Lubbock County
Brad Benson
Chuck Wright
Allan Wood
Terry Franklin
Self - Forensic Scientist, Washington State Patrol
Mark Garrett
Janice Poissant
Self - David Castor's Ex-Wife
Paul Iannace
Jim Smith
Self - Rhonda's Father
Jesse Fruhwirth
Self - Investigative Reporter, City Weekly
Michael D. Norton
Kathryn Rogers
Self - Joanna's Mother
Robert Boyle
Self - Dickinson College
Dwight A. Edwards
Self - Darke County Wildlife Officer
Bill Loughery
Chris Breunig
Caitlin Biship
Karin Strom
Kimberley Whitehead
Self - Ronald's Daughter
H. Stanley Rebert
Self - York County District Attorney
Christine Garvey
Self - Chief Assistant District Attorney, Onondaga Co.
Randy Strong
Self - Maryville Police Department
Lawrence Knapp
Barb Hayes
Chyleen Fowler
Self - Dana's Mother
Tray Payne
Self - Lubbock County District Attorney's Office
Tim Barker
Self - York County District Attorney's Office
Todd Cameron Grey
Self - Chief Medical Examiner, State of Utah
Don Fischbach
Self - Glee Ewell's Friend
Don Frtiz
Self - Cameron Police Department
Tom Smith
Dennis Santos
Margie Estrada
Self - Summer's Friend
Scott Tompkins
Bryan Scamman
JP Bensen
Vanessa Ross
Corey Parker
Christopher Troy
Tristan Jenson
Angie Gega
Linda
Stephen Day
Self - Edmond Police Department
Anelia Dyoulgerova
Jogger
Gregory DePetro
Park Manager
Denny Dormody
Irish cop
Kate Stewart
Carrie's Mother
Daniel Van Dyke
Chris Shortt
Jewel Greenberg
Special Agent Shutt
Heath Pennington
Meghan Landowski
Christopher Violette
Randy Swaney
Mario E. Garcia
Officer Paul Watson
James Hamm
Dana Shutt
Self - Naval Criminal Investigative Service
Maki Becker
Self - Reporter, The Buffalo News
Glenn Langenburg
Self - Forensic Scientist, Minnesota BCA
Lourdes Zapata
ACTOR
Gregory Savage
Self - Erie Co. Sheriff's Office
Matthew Frank
Self - Assistant Attorney General
Josh Keats
Self - New York State Police
J.P. Martin
Self - Portsmouth Police Department
Megan Harkleroad
Self - Meghan's Friend
Jim Stokes
Self - Criminalist Supervisor, OSBI
Ken Case
Self - Erie County Deputy District Attorney
John Simich
Self - Erie County Forensics Examiner
Evan Verbrugge
Self - Rock County Sheriff's Office
Steve Nigrelli
Paul Soppeland
Self - Minnesota BCA
Dianne Clary
Self - Gary Larson's Sister
Kristine Deters
Donald Wright
Self - Amherst Police Department
Victoria Van Spyk
Self - Linda Yalem's Friend
Earle C. Mobley
Self - Commonwealth's Attorney, City of Portsmouth
Lori Ehde
Self - Editor, Rock County Star Herald
Chuck Goode
Greg Elwell
Self - Former Reporter, Daily Oklahoman
Joel Mikle
Self - Field Conservation Officer, Minnesota DNR
J. Douglas Perkins
Robert McDaniel
Scott Patronik
Mike Riley
Self - Gary's Friend
Steven T. Goldman
Susan Roe
Self - Asst. Medical Examiner, Regina Medical Center
Jack Potter
Self - Linda Yalem's Former Boyfriend
Elizabeth Schneider
Self - Analyst, New York State Police
Jeffrey Wieneke
Robert Barney
Self - Joan Diver's Brother
Douglas H. Funkhouser
Diane Dennis
Self - Joan Diver's Sister
Self - Meghan's Stepfather
Angela Shortt
Self - Meghan's Mother
Frank Sedita
Self - Erie County District Attorney
Kenny Catlett
William R. Martin
Carl Sequeira
Alan Rozansky
Suzette Tomlinson
Teenager
Christine Mazur
Self - Majane Mazur's Daughter
Dennis Delano
Self - Buffalo Police Department
Michael Beebe
Clyde Menning
James Mirusso
Jeff Hancock
Jeff Karr
Self - Carrie's Uncle
Julie Nicotra
Carrie Nelson
Self - Suspect
Chris Weber
Jason Johnson
Dishwasher(uncredited)
Emory Rundle
Brother(uncredited)
Matt J. Doyle
Detective(uncredited)
Steven Fuel
Drug Dealer(uncredited)
Bruce Van Patten
Officer James Choate(uncredited)
Josephine Gorchoff
Jane Doe(uncredited)
Woody Andrews
Inmate Rosdale(uncredited)
Roman Marshanski
Robert Denney(uncredited)