Nightmare Next Door (2011) | Full Cast

Claire Callahan

DIRECTOR

Iwonka Swenson

DIRECTOR

Bethany McMahon

DIRECTOR

Anne Rothwell

DIRECTOR

Edward Hydock

DIRECTOR

Rachel Sikora

DIRECTOR

Greg Diefenbach

Narrator

James Davenjay

Detective

Dorian Lough

Narrator

Tom Gambrill

Bob

Peter Muggleworth

Bar Patron

Vince Eisenson

Eddie Wooten

Donald Imm

Detective Travis Higginbotham

Wes Overby

Detective

Matt Gulbranson

Detective Kevin Day

Joe Barlam

Eric

Chuck Taber

Aaron Carpenter

Mike Sutton

Dectective 1

Juan Eloy Carrera

CSI Agent

Pete Garvey

Chris Orlando

Jimmy Bacon

Jennings, Colton

Ali Dash

Cleaning Lady

Erin L. Rind

Dawn's Mom

Edward M. Kelahan

Investigator

Dallas White

Christopher

Luba Hansen

Aunt Jackie

Marcus Gogas

Alan Schurman

Jonathon Ruckman

Detective Townsend

Kelli Miller

Fiancee

Gavin Peretti

Dean Harris

Zoltan L. Nagy

Detective

Anne Marie Moneta

Debra Rawls

Lucky Harmon

Lead Role of Killer

Natalie Cassell

Mother of Victim

W. Keith Scott

Father Mr. Williams

Allison Howard

Cheryl Burnett

Chris Conlon

Detective

Dylan Denmark

Bar patron

Mike Beckner Jr.

Bartender

Elliott Bales

Stanley Hyman

Hillary Styer

Bar Patron

Ulysses E. Campbell

James Fountain

Alexis Barone

Christie

Mark Vincent

Mason

Kimberly Brown

April

Bonnie Webster

Detective Jones

Brooks Skiles

Construction Worker

Cory Cunningham

Detective Jody

Sonia Debreczeni

Detective Allyson Johnson

Erin Nordseth

Diane Collins

Candice 'CJ' Johnson

Club Patron

Lisa Coryell

Self - Crime Writer

Scott Zeiss

Coworker

Igor Bransteter

Cory Vankeuren

Terry Loveman

Detective 2

Will Steckman

Freddy Monroe

Todd Bobenrieth

Detective Flickinger

Jason Stolfi

Detective

Emery Erin

Party Girl

Johnny Jengo

CSI Agent

Beth Barnes

Female Detective

Eric Supensky

Detective Smith

Camryn Gulbranson

Amber

Robert Olausen

Main Deputy

Ronald Woodhead

Ed Cronell

Tony Barber

Jim Larson

Shelly Long

Caren Campano

Don Whatley

Detective Douglas Demangone

Benjamin Loeh

Police Officer

Ricardo Sosa Jr.

John Ward

S. Pierre Paret

Ben Dennerlein

Lisa Celia

Mary Stetson (Victim)

Kevin Sidenstricker

Dennis Woodruff

Tracey Allyn

Kathryn Hauser (lead)

Courtney Dykstra

Shelly Vogel

Ryan A. Phillips

Michael Severence

Alexander Pennecke

Brandon Woodruff

Steven Gross

Rucker Leifson

Irvin Kalugdan

Daniel Willyam

Vaughn Bullard

Dale Eaton

Brandon Tamburri

Kirk Reilly

Cindy Jackson

Counselor

Caleb McDaniel

Timmy Olson

Ryan Scott Thomas

Dan Welch

Kazarr

Investigator

Sam McCrea

Patient

Chad A. Fehr

Robert Meek

Kate Volpe

Kelee Davidson

Corey Bente

Jarrod Davidson

Glenn Bukata

Self - Detective

Altorro Prince Black

Red Herring

Jason Ford

Robert Barnes

Samuel Muriithi

Walter McKenzie Jr.

Dylan Hintz

Kirk Walt

WBBrown II

Reggie

Chris J. Duncan

Main Suspect

Matt Marberry

Matt Self

Richard Patterson

Eddie Williams

Elizabeth Klein

KIm

S.A. Steven Holmes

N.C. State Bureau of Investigation

Ken Copeland

Self - Homicide Detective

Hugo Del Granado

Cortez

Brian Mullahy

Self - KUTV News Reporter

Will Haza

Brian Earley

Nancy Self

Self

James Jones

Self

Charlie Dreizen

Joe's Son

Danny 'atomicgoofball' Nguyen

Angelo shin

Sean Donegan

Max

Sydney Wilson

Self

Mary Myers

Angela

Douglas H. Funkhouser

Self - Det., Portsmouth Police Dept.

Edward Robert Bach

Eric

Diana Tilton

Homicide Detective

Clarence Montgomery

Self - Woods Cross Police Dept. (Ret.)

Lacey Elliot

Michele Harris

Drew Caudell

Self

Chris Shortt

Self - Meghan's Stepfather

Rodrick Loritts

Self - Brittany's Father

Kelli Derrick

Self - Megan's Dance Teacher

Robert McDaniel

Self - Det., Portsmouth Police Dept.

Carl Sequeira

Self - Forensic Tech, Portsmouth Police Dept.

Rick Burk

Glen Smith

David Whisenant

Self - WBTV News Reporter

Rose Iebba

Mystery Woman

J.D. Barber

Self - Det., Salisbury Police Department (ret.)

Brad Benson

Self - Woods Cross Police Dept.

Shawn Pratt

Self

Brent Hall

Self - Det., Salisbury Police Department

Heather Corl

Self - Meghan's Friend

Lynard Barbosa

Self

Asti Loritts

Self - Brittany's Sister

Coco Saltzgiver

Self - Karin's Sister

Blair Bowers

Laura Wynn

Angela Shortt

Self - Meghan's Mother

Troy Rawlings

Self - Davis County Attorney

Christina Pagonis

Alyssa

Virginia Tucker

Lead

Mark McKinnon

Junior

Lori Fullbright

Self - KOTV News

Jenna St. John

Candy

Shannon Lanier

Detective Scott Harakles

Reuel Belt

Gary

Tom Ukah

Robert Parker

Annika Cowles

Mason's daughter

Zach Steffey

Drake Watson

John Newsom

Self

Jessica Hutson

Zilpha Lowery

Bart Debicki

Braxton Fields

Jon Rand

Narrator

John Doty

Detective

Gary B. Gross

Sales Clerk

Ben Benson

Self - Det. Sgt., Pierce County Sheriff's Dept.

Robin Zerbe

Ginger Pavey

Carl Stevens

Jesus Lookalike Boyfriend

Christa A. Feldi

Neighbor

P.J. Megaw

Dan Henner

Shane Donovan

Bar Patron

Virginia Coffield

Breanna

Cord Buckner

Self - Det., Wausau Police Dept.

Hayden Livesay

Nolan

Michael Huff

Self - Det., Tulsa Police Department

Terry McConnaughey

Jacob Bard

Wyatt Unger

James

Sharon Carpenter-Rose

Beth Grosskopf

Nina Fowler

Bizanowicz's Girlfriend

Telisha L. Davis

Shauna Tyner

Molly Shen

Self - KOMO-TV Anchor

William Dreyer

Self - Officer, Freedom Borough Police

Bill Higgins

Self - Bedford County D.A.

Terry Moore

Self - Lt., Missouri State Highway Patrol (ret.)

J. Patrick Sullivan

Self - Former Stone County Prosecutor

Jeff Stark

Self - Wausau Daily Herald

Julie Ann Garvey

Stacie Smith

Gabe Fremuth

Daniel Woloson

Amy Markle

Self - Former WTAJ-TV Reporter

Erika O'Bar

Joanne Presti

Chastity Grubb

Self - Holly's Daughter

Bryant Wells

Self - Major, Texas Rangers

Elizabeth Abate

Rita

Craig Grassmyer

Self - Trooper, Pennsylvania State Police

Bill Vidonic

Self - Pittsburgh Tribune Review

Rod Sievers

Self - Former WSIL-TV Reporter

Theresa Wetzsteon

Self - Deputy D.A. Marathon County D.A.'s Office

Ken Welch

Self - Jerry's Boyfriend

William Cunningham

Self - Billie's Son

Logan Grubb

Self - Holly's Son

Andrea Hahn

Self - Former Southern Illinoisian Reporter

Nancy Pranskey

Self - Beth's Friend

Rebecka Sacrey

Bar Patron

Craig Schneller

Self - Breanna's Father

Rob Bailey

Self - Officer, Navasota Police Department, (former)

James Wilson

Self - Deputy, Pierce County Sheriff's Dept.

Dwayne Isringhausen

Self - Captain, Missouri State Highway Patrol

Courtney Chamberlain

Self - Rob Chamberlain's Daughter

Ryan Moiles

Jeffrey Russ Gorman

Kim A. Clments

Self - Lt., Beaver County Detectives Bureau

Amy Conley

Renee Powell

Grace Doughty

Misty

Matt Barnes

Self - Det., Wausau Police Dept.

Eben Kuhns

Tyler Green

Travis Higginbothan

Self - Det., Grimes County D.A.'s Office

Mike Rogers

Self - Sgt., Missouri State Highway Patrol (ret.)

Kirsten Wilson

Self - Fmr., Asst. Attorney General

Joanne Rowe

Self - Pen's friend

Lottie Doughty

Tiana

Roger Smith

Self - Cpl., Pennsylvania State Police (ret.)

Jason Tate

Self - Det., Pierce County Sheriff's Dept.

Tuck McLain

Self - D.A., Grimes County D.A.'s Office

Karen Slater

Self - Bev's Mom

Chris Kalman

Steven Wilson

Michael Morey

Self - Det. Sgt., Michigan State Police

Sarah Lomke

Susan Schumake

Martin Vann

Self - Det., Tulsa Police Department

Rick Straubel

Self - Deputy, Ionia County Sheriff's Office

Francesca Gonzalez

Girl at Party

Caroline O'Grady

Samantha

Lori Cunningham

Self - Billie's Daughter

Paul Piskoty

Self - Officer, Wausau Police Dept.

Chuck Jordan

Self - Chief, Tulsa Police Department

Brian Sieman

Self - Trooper, Michigan State Police

John Feather

Self - Cpl., Pennsylvania State Police

Janet Dailey

Self - Mayor, Hubbardston Michigan

Eric Berube

Self - Trooper, New Hampshire State Police

Ron Grubb

Self - Holly's Fiance'

Russell Lamson

Self - Detective Sgt., New Hampshire State Police

Lawson Turner

Self - Lonnie Sr.'s Brother

Timothy Lally

Ronald

Glen Carroll Haupt

Detective Simpson

Lianna Brizzi

Bar Patron

Rob Chamberlain

Self - Detective., Beaver County Detectives Bureau

Chris Steeley

Brian Mauck

Bob Lewandowski

Bobby Taylor

Carly Dreizen

Brenda

Matthew Justin Williamson

Eduardo

Paul Echols

Self - Lt., Carbondale Police Dept. (ret)

Susannah Wells

Terri Clendenen

Kierstin Lindkvist

Friend #2

Cynthia Reardon Phillips

Self - Olive G. Pettis Library

Brandon Mitchell

Police Informant

Ellyn McLaughlin

Edith 'Pen' Meyer

Jason Almstrom

Self - Trooper, New Hampshire State Police

Heather Callahan-Stevens

Delores

Joe Brown

Self - Former KBTX Reporter

Lowell McGee

Self - Lt., SIU Police Department (ret)

Chris McMullin

Self

Connie Lamothe

Chloe Winslow

Jesse Robinson

Basketball Player

Amy Mack

Sherita

Marc Goodman

Abe Shurman

Emily Whitworth

Izzy Wholaver

Victoria Anastasi

Sonia

Kevin Flynn

Self

Andrew Aninsman

Self

Gina Grinkemeyer

Bar Patron

William Waddell Jr.

Thug Friend #2

Chelsea Reba

Bar Patron

Annie K. Fox

Christie

Isaac Reeb

Lonnie

Ken Maurice Purnell

Kid

J.D. Wine

Steve Barlowe

Raven Charles

Tina

Pete Bergen

Cop

Elizabeth Brent

Betsy Schurman

Firas Natour

Greg

Christina Nelson

ACTOR

Allison Tucker

Rose Dellinger

Michele Jones

Self - Vernie's Sister

Jack Repsha

Self - Capt., New Jersey State Police

Bill Peterson

Hal Smith

Wayne Griffith

Self - Rev., Lighthouse Outreach Ministries

Charles Hall

Self - Det., Trenton Police Department (ret.)

David Kenneth Sommerville

Robber

Kathy Flicker

Self - Mercer County 1st Asst. Prosecutor

Michael Cosmo

Self - Det., Trenton Police Department (ret.)

John Byrne

Martin Byerly

Robert Billings

Self - Capt., New Jersey State Police

Michael Briegel

Self - Assistant Prosecutor, Sussex County New Jersey (ret)

Ginnie Littell

Self - Christine's Friend

Parker Space

Self - Owner, Space Farms Zoo

Laura Scott Ferro

Carmela Dawson

Ben Ryan Metzger

Eric Wade Smith

Charles Mitchell

Self - Vernie's Father

Caleb Wade

Owen Gardner

Mary Richards

Christine Schurman

Samantha Merrick

Jan Waters

Lyneka Estee

Bartender

Richard Dennis Johnson

Hampton

Alex Witherow

Brad

Jeff Couillard

Lucas Adelson

Chris Andreychak

Self - Lt. Col., New Jersey State Police (ret)

Johnny Alonso

Jake Mallard

Radford Baker

Fisherman

Tim Torre

Dustin

CJ Williams

Frist Responder Cop

Paula Black

Danielle Davis-Lead Role

Victoria Stevens

911 Caller

Lizzie Mears

Amy

Paul Cottman

Boyfriend

Antonio Jefferson

Ted weathers

Ariel Myren

Charla Woodruff

Cameron Ring

Todd Gerald

Jennifer Keller

Shirley Stark

Kevin Leigh

FBI Sketch Artist

Kenneth Wayne

Laurence Lovejoy

Emily Roos

Kelsey Monahon

Julio Bana Fernandez

Brandon Myers

Paul H Chapman

Randy Sharp

Cole Elliott

Police Officer

Robert Renzi

Brother

Andrew Hunsicker

Detective #1

Jequan Jackson

Trent Floyd

Augusta Meyers

Self - Kathryn's Colleague

Darrin Archer

Detective

Akiba Robinson

Gloria Dunn

Demetrius Stephens

Luis Avana

Matthew Shea

Adam Peterson

David Waymire

Self - Deputy DA, Albuquerque NM

Diana Abrecht

Lisa

Amanda Kay Livezey

Student

Chris Perillo

Matt

Martha McConnell

Vanessa

Brian Foreman

Steve Aiken

Jason Whitaker

CSI Agent Watkins

Christopher Zash

Erik

Kathryn Browning

Samantha Mader

Dave Ferrier

EMT

Keith Kuperman

Joel Marino

John Wells

Roger Orr

Hugo Ciarrocchi

Brent Wakeman

Jamal Alkhaldi

Landscape Worker

Stephanie Ray Glass

Cynthia Rolle

Faith Nelson

Jessyca Arro

Gary Ayash

Bret Michaels, Murder Suspect

Harold Shenk

Self - Det., Berks County D.A.

Shira Bethea

Janet

Kristin Poklemba

Maggie Haines

Kathy Nixon

Self - Kari's mom

Dena Bleu

Rosa Lewis

Stacy Gedney

Casey's Wife

Kierra Spruill

Friend

Mackie Lou Vigal

Teen Girl Caller

Vincent Conway

Trooper Al Lesco

Katie Runnerstrom

Murderer's Wife

Lori DesLauriers

Self - Kari's sister

Joshua Pigatt

Carl Jeffries

Kristen Egermeier

Mallory

Jose L. Penaranda

Sex ofender

Allyson Berger

Lisa Kimmell

Nate Nelson

Warden

Noah Moore

Tony Davis

Simone Walker

Daughter in livingroom

Ned Read

Detective

Peter Chiamardas

Detective Oliver

Alexandra Bradley

Party Girl

Russell Popham

Self - Captain., East Point Police Department

Wade Irwin

Self - Det., Chittenango Police Dept.

Kevin Joel Anderson

Detective

Mikayla Kelley

Rita Fillapone

Kathryn Hauser

Self

James Nevins

Police Detective

Rita Filippone

Christine's friend

Larry Bailey

Self - Arapahoe County Deputy DA

Andrea Fogelberg

Self - Neighbor

Emily Sucher

Stacy Kimmell

Craig Stedman

Self - District Attorney, Lancaster, PA

Nasiyr McGill

Terrence McNeal

Thomas Nedell

Self - Officer, Chittenango Police Dept.

Troy Michel

Janelle Harris

Marisa Tasheuras

Jennifer Leonard

Jennifer Leonard

Self - Lori's SIster

Morgan Warner

Self - School Resource Officer, (ret.)

Mark Beachy

Thomas Haines

Don Meyers

Self - Salt Lake City Tribune

Matthew Misener

Lieutenant of Madison P.D.

Kelli Pagano

Christine's friend

Taylor Olivia Burrell

Tiffany Durst

John Wettlaufer

Self - Det., Mannheim Township PD

Peter Page

Self - Trenton Times Reporter

James Driver

Ross Brady

Michael Carioscia

Construction Foreman

Crystal Arnold

Self - Jessyca's Best Friend

Steve Finch

Self - Kathryn's Neighbor

Kazz Felix-Hawver

Kevin Haines

Roger Orr

Self - Shooting Victim

Debbie Marino

Joel's Stepmother

Tamara Davis

Self - Kiplyn's Mother

Bernard Malone Jr.

Self - Former Federal Prosecutor, NY

Richard Davis

Self - Kiplyn's Father

Timothy Durst

Self - Tiffany's Father

Dustin Delatore

Self - Lori's Nephew

Joan Dunnder

Kelsey's mother

Jared Mcallister

Matt Correll

Lavenna George

Self - Terence's Mother

Nicole Sliwka

Travis's Girlfriend

Joline Gutierrez Krueger

Self - Newspaper Columnist

Aaron w Bell

Ambrose harris

Maddie Chapman

Extra

Ben Church

Josh Fredrickson

Corinda Sparks

Self - Antonio Stephney's Sister

Hannah Eileen

Kari Lynn Nixon

Beth Warren

Self - Reporter, Atlanta Journal-Constitution (fmr.)

Carmen J. Salvatore

Self - Det., Trenton PD (ret.)

Lou Marino

Joel's Father

Allen Leed

Self - Det., Mannheim Township PD

Bobby Gray

Self - Det., East Point Police Department

Madison Chapman

Extra

Mark Sokolovich

Self - Ofc., Laureldale Police Dept.

Doug Weaver

Self - Det., Berks County DA's Office

Doug Cloud

Self - Cynthia's Supervisor

Monica Muller

Susan Rigsby

James King

Detective

Matt Monahon

Kelsey's husband

Lisa Wassel

Lisa Haines

Peter Orvetti

Bartender

Steve Adams

Self - Chief, Spanish Fork Police Dept.

Scott Smith

Self - The Record Reporter

Cody Heuer

Scott Henson

Brooke Best

ACTOR

Rene Dechaine

Detective #2

Dawn Arro

Self - Jessyca's Mother

Ronald Fisher

Self - Chief, Laureldale Police Dept.

Josephine Patane

Sherry Kimmell

Eryn Gleason

Christine Lazzaro

Michael Histand

Self - Sgt., Lower Makefield PD

Tim Barge

Self - Det., East Point Police Department

Jarreau Williams

Phillip Busey - lead

Jennifer Giannotti-Perroto

Self - Audrey's Mom

Sarah Ragsdale

Lynette Jarrett

Rachel Klein-Kircher

Nathan's Mother

Zoe Aaron

Self - Kristin's Friend

Kate Wolosyn

Self - Neighbor

Trooper Mark Revette

Self - New York State Police

Michael Cuneo

Self - Author, A Need to Kill

Frank Lazzaro

Christine's father

Bill Carey

Self - YNN Reporter

Dave Oliver

Self - Sgt. San Joaquin County Sheriff's Office

Richard Sypek

Self - New York State Police

Wess Brooker

Justin Archer

George Brauchler

Self - Arapahoe Country District Attorney

Richard Lambert

Self - Asst. U.S. Attorney (ret.)

John Adams

Self - Berks County D.A.

Stacy Fuson

Martha Moxley

Quincey Leigh

Jen

Christopher R. Anderson

Police Officer

Meg Scanlon

Woman #1

Jean Fiumara

Margaret

Ira Grossman

Detective

George Juice Graham

Ben

Peggy Davis

Diane Johnson

John C. Bailey

Billy Fagan

Bianca Allaine

Paul's Wife

Lawrence Derx

Jeremy Bergland

Matthew LaBenz

Richard

William Machuca

Police Officer

Jordan Marx

Girlfriend

Patrick McCarrick

Self - Captain, St.Charles Police Dept.

Colin McHugh

David Czinki

Dave Fairbanks

Detective Ted Nee

Noel Martin

Self - Sgt., Smith County Sheriff's Department

Gemma Davimes

Coven Friend

Jordan Irby

Chris

Brendan Petak

Coven Friend

Jeff Ashton

Self - State Attorney, Orange & Osceola County

Griot Vargas

Claude

Ian A. Wade

Brian

K. Andrew Deffley

Deputy Tom Woodard

Alex Neumeier

Jim

Malcolm Simmons

Supporting

Cara Giambrone

Janice

Donald Stepp

Self - Det., St.Charles Police Dept.

Vivian Thompson

Waitress

Joseph D Fisher

Richard

John Hawthorne Smith

Dirk

Charla Woodruff

Self - Dennis and Norma Woodruff's Daughter

Cristen Stephansky

Mail Carrier

Ricardo Kingsbury

Cleo Hines

Jennifer Flohr

Coven Friend

Alexa Ferrara

Kathryn

Colton Braun

Tyler

Colleen Sproull

Carla - Victim

Scott Chapman

Self - Sgt., Macon Police Department

Amanda LaPore

Coven Friend

Michael Kyne

Mushroom Hunter

Greg Harrison

Booker T. Hillary

Anette Collins

Denise's sister

Jennifer Green

Self - Christopher's Sister

Christopher Fleming

Eric Keystone

Ashley Muller

Self - Lauren's Friend

Joy Pope

Marlene Miller

Bill Halbert

Mushroom hunter #2

Kelly Apicella

Self - Debbie's Sister

Danielle Gaines

Self - The Frederick News Post

Jim Larson

Self - Carla's Husband

Janice Rott

Self - Kathey's Mother

Bryan Blankenship

Christopher Campano

Rebecca Burkert

Self - Editor, South Haven Tribune

Cindy Garris

Self - Carla's Co-Worker

Mike McKay

Self - Asst. Prosecutor, Van Buren County Michigan

Scott Tate

Self - St.Charles Chamber of Commerce

Christopher Bond

Cafe Friend

John Linnert

Self - Det., Orange County Sheriff's Department, (ret.)

Brian Thomas Murphy

CSI Tech

Eric Laskowich

Self - Monica's Brother

Kaitlyn Wheeler

Self - Lauren's Sister

Kevin Conklin

Self - Det. Sgt., Michigan State Police

Melanie Bales

Diane

Michael Bedford

Self - Prosecutor, Van Buren County Michigan

John Edgar Barker

Greg

Jonathan Landers

Cafe Friend

Tim Barker

Self - Chief Dep. Prosecutor, York County D.A.'s Office

Xavier Morris

Christopher Briseno

Don Stepp

Self - Det., St.Charles Police Dept.

Kevin Shaffer

Mushroom Hunter

Gabriel Alan Metzger

Coven Friend

Douglas Demangone

Self - Asst. Chief Det., York County D.A.'s Office

Don McFillin

The killer - Danny

Brian Cutter

Detective

Frank Michels

Self - Reporter, Gaylord Herald Times

Dino E. Flores Jr.

Self - Fmr. Asst. State's Attonrey

Kimberly Porter

Keri

Arthur Kraus

Sean

Laura Gepford

Kelly Appicello

Janet Nichol

Self - Mayor Pro Tem

David Cooke

Self - DA, Macon, GA

Zac Brightbill

Billy Jr.

Dan Holloran

Self - Bob's Friend

Zachary Scruggs

Scott Shrake

Kevin Hesselink

Self - Fmr. Prosecutor, Otsego County, MI

Dean Meyer

Self - Officer, St.Charles Police Dept.

Lisa Layden

Self - Det., Southwestern Regional Police Dept.

Kathleen Green

Self - Christopher's Mother

Linda Matthews

Self - Norma's Sister

Debbie Salamone

Self - Fmr. Reporter of the Orlando Sentinel

Edward Hydock

Anonymous Caller

Jesse Parish III

Zeke (Billy's Best Friend)

Veronica Somers

Brandy

Jeff Collins

Self - Lt., Texas Rangers

Ted Nee

Self - Lt., Frederick County Sheriff's Office

Kevin Day

Self - Det. Sgt., Michigan State Police (ret.)

Matthew Purpora

Employee

Brandon Woodruff

Self

Tom Woodard

Self - Dep., Orange County Sheriff's Department, (ret.)

Jonathan Ingbretson

Tim

Bill Groenweghe

Self - Prosecutor, St.Charles County

Dan Hill

Self - Det., Traverse City Police Department (ret.)

Mike Matthews

Self - Officer, Southwestern Regional Police Dept.

Latasha Kennedy

Tanya

Debbie Tsamoudakis

Cindy

Sarah Giddings

Self - Lauren's Sister

Mike Burns

Self - Chief, Macon Police Department, (ret.)

Amy Leigh Womack

Self - Reporter, The Telegraph

Kelly Nelson

Self - Sr. Dep. Prosecutor, York County D.A.'s Office

Elisabeth Rayle

Debbie Fagan

Christian Yancich

Police Officer

Jason M. Hamel

Detective Hill

Kathleen Kemp

Self - Debbie's Friend & Co-Worker

Steven Tyler Foote

Jacob Wheeler

Ron Howard

Dan Short

Maureen McCormick

Marian Justi

Rachel Keefe

Trudy

Dorian Lopinto

Nancy Newman

Gemma McIlhenny

Easter Mcclain

William Lash

Hank

Dan Poole

Detective

Rebekah Hart Franklin

Veronica Bozza

Kelly Schwartz

Michelle

Justin Sisk

Brad Lowell

Christopher Winter

Lucas Mathews

David Neil Cohen

Medical Examiner

Laura Zollinhofer

Art Teacher

Rolfini Whidbee

Police Officer

Emilee Kerwin

Reka

Ana Markova

Crissy

Amber Gwin

Nicki Margo

Yasmin Qudah

Club Girl

Jeannine Reardon

Self - Writer and Attorney

Mary Ataku

Lacey

Sarah Scheiner

Jamie Letson

John Paul Andrews

Timothy Bozza

Julie Bell

Michelle Zammitti

Meredith Sullivan

Shelley Nance

Richard Zane

Lewis Shae

Jesse Milliner

Jake Donovan

Jerome Smith

Officer Peterson

Moses Bernal

Ethan

Shawn Abraham

Male Friend

Patrick McCarthy

Mr. Foster

Jake Schloss

Boy

Alicia Styer

Bystander

Krisy Danielle

Megan Danvers

Allie Rueter

Katherine Foster

Janet Devine Smith

Mrs. Pasco

Maggie Tehan

Holly

Eric Cover

John Kowalczyk

Richard Cass

Self - Det., Wakefield Police Dept. (ret)

Maura Harford

Crissy's Mom

Steven Ablondi

Detective

Marshall Bailey

Travis

Justin Catches

Detective

Nadia Smith

Christina Benjamin

Jaxon Keller

Ryan Kowalczyk

Matthew DeHoff

Sam

Sean M. Brown

Manager Coolfont Resort

Kevin Baker

Self - Trooper, Massachusetts State Police

Rachel Jones

Dawn

Gus Zucco

Shambaugh

Jennifer K. Schultz

Teacher

Sophia Creed

Angie Newman

Gregory Townsend

Detective

Mario Nelson

Brian King

Wayne Micheal Cox

Judd Owens

Anna Jackson

Roommate

Rebecca Norris

Melissa Newman

Rick Smith

Self - Chief, Wakefield Police Dept.

Dave Cooperman

Ronnie Willis

Anastasiya Orlova

Susie

Isabella Garcia

Molly

Charles Turchiano

Priest

Andrew Injaychock

Self

Arrington Foster

Friend

Ayanna S. Flemings

Mrs. Riggs

Anthony Hackett

First Responder

Darren Alford

Vernie Mitchell

Gary Lavard

Clarence Williams

Nathan Gadsden

Papa Mitchell

Matt Jones

Anthony Foskey

Tarrence Taylor

Damon Barnes

Justin Byers

Troy Riggs

Shaunyce Lee

Michelle Mitchell

Dan Verkman

Good Samaritan, 911 Caller (uncredited)

David Seemiller

Edward Owens (uncredited)

Leah Young

Holly (uncredited)

Lenny Le

Kramer Lee (uncredited)

Lauren Cox

Suspect's Girlfriend (uncredited)

Thomas Lee Johnson

Kevin Edison Smith - Serial Killer (uncredited)

Kimia' Workman

CSI Agent (uncredited)

Tracy Sabo

Audrey (uncredited)

Ed Higgins

Chief Ron Fisher (uncredited)

Michael Marcan

Officer Sokolovich (uncredited)