Two Shallow Graves: The McStay Family Murders (2022) | Full Cast

Justin Lee Stanley

DIRECTOR

Tony Azzaro

Michael McFadden

Raj Maline

Self - Defense Attorney

Taylor Jarvis

Self - Chase Merritt's Daughter

Michael Pate

Jim McGee

Dan Kavanaugh

Self - Employee of Joseph McStay

Suzanne Armstrong

Cathy Jarvis

Melissa Rodriguez

Self - Prosecuting Attorney

Chase Merritt

Self - Convicted of a Quadruple Murder

Shawn Patrick Murphy

Chase Merritt

Ryan Smith

Self - Lt. at the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department

Patrick McStay

Self - Father of Joseph McStay

Sean Daugherty

Self - Prosecuting Attorney

Adam Bemis

Joseph McStay

Michael A. Smith

Self - Judge for San Bernardino County Courts, California

Catherine Jarvis

Self - Chase Merritt's former girlfriend

Britt Imes

Self - Prosecuting Attorney

Michael James McFadden

Self - Husband of Joseph McStay's ex-wife Heather

James McGee

Self - Defense Attorney

Michael McStay

Self - Brother of Joseph McStay

John McMahon

Self - Sheriff at the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department

Gina Watson

Self - Friend of Joseph McStay

Ellen Valinotti

Jim's Wife

Adam J. Jackson

Detective Hanke (uncredited)