I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (1998)

A year after a tragic accident, Julie returns to school with persistent nightmares. She finds solace in her new friend, Will. Julie's best friend, Karla, plans a Bahamas trip to set Julie up with Will, but her ex, Ray, still lingers in her thoughts. When Ray learns the killer Ben Willis is alive, he races to warn Julie, but they get trapped on the island by a storm. As deaths mount, it's clear the fisherman killer is targeting Julie.