Shattered Hopes: The True Story of the Amityville Murders - Part I: From Horror to Homicide (2011) | Full Cast

Ryan Katzenbach

DIRECTOR

Edward Asner

Narrator

Remy Bogna

Allison DeFeo

Don Bonander

Juror

Wendy Bonander

Jury Forewoman

Shawn Bordoff

William E. Weber

Josh Bower

Gerard Sullivan

D.T. Carney

Detective

Chris Connell

Billy Davidge

Terra Davenport

Juror

Allison DeFeo

Self (archiveFootage)

Dawn DeFeo

Self (archiveFootage)

John Matthew DeFeo

Self (archiveFootage)

Marc DeFeo

Self (archiveFootage)

Geraldine DeFeo-Gates

Self

Agnes Dosio

Juror

Robin Fernandez

Juror

Josie Franzia

Juror Rosemary

John Gray

Frank Boyde

Lindsey Hager

Dawn DeFeo

Tom Harris

Detective

Tom Harris

Detective #2

Eric Hickey

Self - Forensic Criminologist

Alexandra Holzer

Self

Hans Holzer

Self (archiveFootage)

Jon Huybrecht

Ronald J. DeFeo Jr.

Ron Iverson

Juror

Susannah Hart Jones

Geraldine DeFeo

Roxanne Salch Kaplan

Self

Carolyn Katzenbach

Juror

McKenna Reese Katzenbach

Stephanie DeFeo - 2 months old

Ron Katzenbach

Juror

Ryan Katzenbach

Self

Rich Kreps

Herman Race

Brenda Lee

Kathleen Lutz

George Lutz

Self

Kathy Lutz

Self

Diana Maiocco

Louise Brigante-DeFeo

Joel Martin

Self

Michelle Netzley

Juror #8 - Peg Giambra - 25

Ric Osuna

Self

Bill Pfeiffer

Forensic Dive Coordinator

Kent Phillips

George Lutz

Bo Prieto

Offr. Kenneth Greguski

Kathleen Puckett

Self - Forensic Criminologist

Herman H. Race

Self (archiveFootage)

Michael Race

Self

Adam Sass

Augie DeGennaro

Marvin Scott

Self

David Shae

Bobby Kelske

Geoffrey Smith

Juror

Jon Southwell

Ronald DeFeo Sr.

Cheryl Vickers

Juror

Rick Walden

Suffolk County Courier

Harold Wiest

Juror

Wesley Winter

Coroner

John Wright

Judge Thomas Stark