Stars (in credits order)
Hank Aaron
Himself - NL pinch-hitter
George Altman
Luis Aparicio
Himself - AL infielder
Ernie Banks
Himself - NL infielder
Frank Bolling
Himself - NL second baseman
Ken Boyer
Jackie Brandt
Himself - AL pinch-hitter
Jim Bunning
Himself - AL pitcher
Smoky Burgess
Himself - NL starting catcher
Norm Cash
Himself - AL starting first baseman
Orlando Cepeda
Himself - NL starting left fielder
Roberto Clemente
Himself - NL starting right fielder
Rocky Colavito
Himself - AL starting left fielder
Shag Crawford
Himself - Second base umpire
Dick Donovan
Cal Drummond
Himself - Right field umpire
Roy Face
Himself - NL pitcher
Whitey Ford
Mike Fornieles
Nellie Fox
Himself - AL pinch runner, second baseman
Jim Gentile
Himself - AL pinch hitter, first baseman
Elston Howard
Himself - AL catcher
Dick Howser
Himself - AL third baseman
Al Kaline
Himself - AL center fielder
Eddie Kasko
Harmon Killebrew
Himself - pinch hitter, third baseman
Sandy Koufax
Tony Kubek
Himself - AL starting shortstop
Stan Landes
Himself - Home plate umpire
Frank Lary
Art Mahaffey
Mickey Mantle
Himself - AL Center Fielder
Roger Maris
Himself - AL starting right fielder
Eddie Mathews
Himself - NL starting third baseman
Willie Mays
Himself - NL starting center fielder
Mike McCormick
Stu Miller
Danny Murtaugh
Himself - NL manager
Stan Musial
Himself - NL pinch hitter
Camilo Pascual
Bob Purkey
Paul Richards
Himself - AL manager
Brooks Robinson
Himself - AL starting third baseman
Frank Robinson
Himself - NL left fielder
Johnny Romano
Himself - AL starting catcher
John Roseboro
Himself - NL catcher
Ed Runge
Himself - Third base umpire
Don Schwall
Roy Sievers
Himself - AL pinch hitter
Warren Spahn
Dick Stuart
Johnny Temple
Himself - AL starting second baseman
Frank Umont
Himself - First base umpire
Ed Vargo
Himself - Left field umpire
Bill White
Himself - NL starting first baseman
Hoyt Wilhelm
Maury Wills
Himself - NL starting shortstop
Don Zimmer