Diretor/a
Phoebe Kwong
DIRETOR/A
Joel Pincosy
J. Tom Pogue
Colin Herlihy
Justin Lee Stanley
Bryan C. Marsh
Meaghan Cleary
Elenco (na ordem dos créditos)
Frank Di Napoli
Adult John White
James M. Reilly
Adult Dustin
T.J. Craig
Josh
Robert Levey II
Corey Breininger
Kathy-Ann Hart
Intake Nurse
John Cerny
Police Officer
Brian Vadim
Bill
David Wenzel
Det Broderick
Marian Murray
Angela Parsons Kreider (Alec's Mom)
Mark Lehneman
Co-worker
Steve Schroko
Grandfather
Jennifer Capri
Mrs. Bass
Laura Cornachio
Sara
Andrew Colford
Peter Tobin
Hillary Hamilton
Candace Sims
Margaret Keller
Self - Paul Keller's Mother
George Keller
Self - Paul Keller's Father
James Zeiss
Detective
Ava Briglia
Lindsay Wrinkles - Young Lindsay
Tim Rerucha
Eric Wrinkles
Amaya Press
Little Sister Ryan (2017)
Adeleen Rosner
Lindsey Wrinkles
Thom Bierdz
Self - Brother of Troy Bierdz
Molly Gazay
Jennifer
Vaden Thurgood
Christian Fuhr
Kyle Merker
Doctor
William W. Wallace
Aaron Christopher Foust
Sawyer Ploski
John Duck (Teen)
James Francis Kellinger
Corrections Officer
Cindy Taylor
Self - Blanche Taylor Moore's Daughter
Vincent Rabil
Self - Assistant District Attorney
Hannah Brahney
Rachels Daughter
Mark Montalbano
FBI Agent
J. Michael Baran
Brooke Turner
Swinger Wife
Laura Rothschild
Diner Patron
Adam Aminov
Young Doug
Benjamin Oduro
Guard
Laurie Kirk
Nora Maher
Estella Sexton
Megan Han Lee
Bartender
Melissa Sutkowski
Clare Bradburn
John Shepard
George Yazguirre
Jack St. Pierre
Young Jack
Christian Carrigan
Michael
Griffin Wallace Henkel
Ron's friend
Trevor Lyons
Andrew Stawicki
Katherine Leidlein
April
Michael Formoso
Young BJ Beebe
River Mason Eromosele
Kabib son
Malcolm A. Chavis
Karim
P.J. Bracco
Cabbie
Michael Stephen Walls
Alan
Isaac J. Conner
Jon Eason
Lenny Grossman
Cristobel Palacio
Leslie Bacon
Cheri Tate
Dannah Basgall
May
Soulo Smith
Elder Thomas
Aaralyn Anderson
Theresa Feury
Luka Danilovich
Son
Bob Gallagher
Attorney
Kali Veronica
Laura Castillo
Jordyn Lauria
Jessica
Victoria Joliddie
Morgan's Daughter
Carrie Charlesworth
CPS Worker
Joel Isaac
Nick Scott
Joe
Max MacKenzie
Brian Britton
Lindsay Wrinkles
Self - Eric Wrinkles Daughter
Susan Hamlin
Self
Khouri St.Surin
Vaughn
Dane West
Gabriel Campos
Estephania LeBaron
Self - Ervil LeBaron's Daughter
Louis Jannuzzi III
Bobby Long (teen)
Gian Shines
Harassing guy
Ross Kugman
Johnny
Alexander Pennecke
Bernard Eugene Giles
Anna Fikhman
Karen Kuzma
Blair Ribero
Nurse
Carmella Kaiser
Child Belinda
Tyler Shore
Sheriff's Deputy
Cameron Balbi
Tyler Worley
Jennifer Hamlin
Self (Susan's daughter)
Andrew Spieker
Brian
Jayani Jalese
Jill Garrison
George Hider
John Wayne Gacy
Clare Hamlin
Lamar K. Cheston
Nathaniel White
Ian Zelbo
Young Jamie
Lacey Caroline
Kendra
Sage Buchalter
Amy
Michael Pate
Paul Winter
Alec Hamlin
Self (Susan's son)
Kristen Doscher
Hitchhiker
Mikhail Latham
Amy's friend
Nicholas Harney
Jamie's Ex Husband
Asen Grigorov
Alexandra Rose Krieger
Beth Cruz
Natalie Roy
Kathy Johnson
Emmy James
Cathy Wilson
Josh Rhett Noble
Keith Johnson
Marc Chouen
Brian Sugrim
Stephen W. Tenner
Jim Cruz
Nikki Lowe
Sheila Cruz
David Cantor
School Principal
John Elefantis
Liz Galalis
Alice Lundgren
Amanda Joy Loth
Bernadette Sugrim
Michael Kelberg
Ronald Hawkins
Eric Jennings
Richard Paul White
Sean Pohle
Robbie Hawkins
Self - Peter Tobin's Ex-Wife
Devan Clark
Danyall White
Bernadette Hyde
Self - Brian Sugrim's Wife
Sydney S Matthews
Suzy Luff
Lindsay Becker
Young Danyall White
Ron Andolsek
Self - Kirtland OH Police Department (ret.)
Scott Rocco
Douglas A. Robbs
Asylum Patient
Marc Wooters
Jeffrey Lundgren
Ron Hawkins
Self - Robbie Hawkin's Father
Self - Robbie Hawkin's Step-Mother
Mark Mucci
The Minder
Gabe Milligan-Green
Kevin Currie
Jessica McHugh
Jenny Janutolo
Erin Wheelock
Richard's Girlfriend
Follower of Jeff Lundgren
Lily Brooks O'Briant
Ayla Schwartz
Tiffany's Friend
Anthony Misiano
James Thimm
David Paul
Jessica Cherniak
Young Tiffany Shore
Helen Laser
Kate
James DeFilippi
Young Brian
Maeve Press
Wallace Jeff's Daughter
Noelle Hogan
Carly
Kristin Samuelson
CPA Agent
Tiffany Hall
Laura Frenzer
Marie Witte
Grayson Eddey
Young Ben Keller
Owen Dammacco
Young Jason
Cortney Gift
Alice Choyce
Oryan Landa
State trooper
Jerry Topitzer
Dennis Britton
Matthew Trygar
Teen Dennis Ryan
Lexie LaPlante
Teen Tiffany
Donny Ness
Young Eric Witte
Adison Eisenberg
Dianne Rothenberg
Mom
Dallin Shea Halls
Brent Jeffs
Ed Bergtold
Anthony Allen Shore
Neely Johnson
Wife
Santiago Mallan
Teen Wallace Jeffs
Christopher Pickhardt
Paul Witte
Kaitlin Campbell
Young Sherry
Micah Chartrand
Paul Keller
Maddox Elliot
Young Dennis Ryan
Hayden Oliver
Teen Paul Keller
Crystal Choyce
Self (Alice & William's daughter)
Shannon Krowicki
Aunt Natalie
Marian Edmiston
Aunt Jenny
Sherry Shafer
Self - Brian Britton's Sister
Michael Buoni
Wallace Jeffs (adult)
Tiani Wright
Teen Crystal Choyce
Linda Lewis
Self (Patrick's mother)
Nate Steinwachs
Warren Jeffs
Beth Woodruff
Sherry
Claire McClanahan
Mother Ryan
Marta Kotzian
Debbie Wrinkles
Charles Mittelstaedt
Self - Chief of Detectives, Poughkeepsie NY Police Department
Devin Hatch
Teen Warren Jeffs
Levi Penley
Adult Sean
Maria Wolf
Scott Churchson
Tim Brownstone
Kayciblu Wright
Young Crystal Choyce
Antoine Hall
Sister's Boyfriend
Christine J. Carlson
Bill Mellen
Detective Mittelstaedt
Adam Cantor
Ryan Hamlin
Alice Swafford
Self (William Choyce's ex-wife)
Maggie Hollinbeck
Tiffany's Aunt
Sean Lewis
Self (Patrick's brother)
Kevin Molduene
Mark Hamlin
Maxwell Wesslock
Young Butch
Wallace Jeffs
Self - Warren Jeff's Half Brother
Colleen Gilbert
Jehovah's Witness
Sheila Ball
Bobby's Mom
Skyler Elyse Philpot
Younger Brooke
George Zouvelos
John Armed Detective
Sophie Sörensen
Shelly Lietz
Rob Moretti
Kevin Dunlap
Elizabeth Vermilyea
Cindy Long
Luz Ozuna
Rachel
Melissa Moore
Self - Keith Jesperson's Daughter
Gillian Todd
Debra Davis
Bernice Wallace
Diane CPS Agent
Vincent Yacovelli
Sexton Child
Mikayla Petrilla
Teen Betty
Jason Collett
Heber
Noah Forrest
Aaron Smallwood Jr.
Young Reggie
Selima Smith-Dell
Young Beverly
Casey Marie Ecker
Teen Cindy
Kelly Mulvihill
Teenage girl
Nicholas Corda
Greg Bierdz
Alex Cioffi
Roslyn Seale
Beverly
Michael Corleone Blanco
Self - Griselda's Blanco's Son
Scott Watson
Bobby Long
Elizabeth Bluhm
Bully Girl 1
Jon Martens
Boy
Nicole Ketchledge
Estephania LeBaron - Teen Years
Eva J.M. Smith
Cindy's Friend (Teen Girl 1)
Brittini Schreiber
Kathy
Jordan Coates
Young Troy
Jesse S. Martin
Officer Hogan
GinaMaria Delio
Teen Ulayla
Andrew Burdette
Brother
Tyler Williamson
Chris
Oriah Elgrabli
Young Linda
Justin Nelson
Willie Sexton
JR Carter
Jill's Brother
Nana Ponceleon
Mother
Alana Barrett-Adkins
Vernetta Ellerbee
Alex Apgar
Young Charles
Vincent Sistrunk
Al Dubinsky
Patricia Lawrence
Grandmother
Logan Raposo
Officer Barry
Harley Yeager
Teen Dean
Mucho Garcia
Clint's Friend
Kalie Swann
Young Pixie
Thomas Cambridge
Eddie Lee Sexton
Cynthia Shaw
Valerie Logan
Kasey Murray
Bobby Joe Long
Alexandra Mesaros
Teen Melissa
Tiffany Iris
Maisel
Graceann Dorse
Rose Jesperson
Erin Shaughnessy
Sister #2
Alyssa Maria App
Daughter
Vongai Shava
Student
Greg Mays
Detective 1
Sophia Guarnaschelli
Madison Mcfarlane
Older Lauren
Courtney Jacoby
Misty Erwin
Hugo Salazar Jr.
Scarpa Driver
Kathryn Mayer
Johnny's Girlfriend
Karen Williams
Self - Richard Ellerbee's Sister
Robert James Hickey
Steve Lichtenstein
Mr. Andrews
Kent R. Williams
Roy
Henry Storrs
Brittany Shaffer
Alanna Stein
Middle Sister
Gregory Barker
Swingers club Patron
Ta-Tanishia Pearson
Ms. Spencer
Lucy Shelby
Ulayla
Zach Catanzaro
Teen Derek
Lukas Max
Troy Bierdz
Self - Nathaniel White's Ex-Girlfriend
Ta'j
Young Vaughn
Stephanie Lehman
Self - Kevin Dunlap's Daughter
Nina Bogosian
Teen Vanessa
Terry Jo Howard
Self - James Randall's Ex-Wife
Chengusoyane Kargbo
Teen Candice
Sherrell-Oliver Riley
Funeral Goer
Lauren Carter Reilly
Pixie Sexton
Dennis Matos
Joe Brewster
Adrian Valle Torres
Rebecca Ross Bailey
Betty
Darren Difalco
Stephan F Feeley
Jacqui Denski
Teacher
Bryden Elliott DiGennaro
Scott
Jacob Levenstien
Derek
Uncle Kevin
Dexter Strong
Robert Rhodes
Mia-Jeanne Frattino
Adult Linda
Brett Singer
DA
Rich Gentilcore
Detective 2
Justin Pontier
Arthur
Mitchell Savitsky
12 year old Troy
Linda Scarpa
Self - Gregory Scarpa's Daughter
Mike Connell
James Taylor
Anthony Duluc
Barfly
Nathan Oesterle
Dean
Jeremy Bar-Illan
Leo
Nicole Cano
Yolanda
Vernetta Cockerham
Self - Richard Ellerbee's Widow
Jason Eric Ross
Keith Jesperson
Emily Jean Ferry
Daughter 2
Hany Osman
Elliot Rivera
Maurice Little
Older Reggie
Adam Link
Walt Chavis
Self - Clay Smith's Brother
Donalia Jones
Jill's Cousin
Drew DeSimone
Jaylen Howe
Young Richard Ellerbee
Jack Malykin
Lewis Perez
Officer Henderson
Avital Hermann
Young Cindy
Josh Dye
Bob
Jasmine Ward
Teen Karen
Scott Manginelli
Natasha Gleichmann
Stephanie Dunlap
Omar Pelaez
Mario
Rob Tromp
Uncle Albert
David Michael McMillan
Detective Crumby
Garrett Swann
Young Son
Linda Wittmier
Kevin Francis Brodie
Officer Johnson
Art Daudelin
Leo Dell
Jerico Bleu
Teen BJ
Ned Pryce
Charles Sexton
Elizabeth Everett
Phyllis
Cindy Brown
Natalie Rosati
LeBaron Child
Andrew G. Black
Father
Zach Abraham
Phoenix Higgins
Richard Ellerbe
Anthony LeDonne
Deputy Johnson
Rich Masotti
ATOR
Kaitlyn Schieble
Young Betty
M. LaVora Perry
Older Beverly
Ruth Rocky
Bar Patron
Siena Corrigan
Melissa's daughter
Valentin Montero
Deputy
Casey Nadzam
Older Brooke
Brooke Lehman
Self - Kevin Dunlap's Ex-Wife
Jennifer Schmidt Ferreira
Griselda Blanco
James Malcom
Groom
Carlos Silva
Swinger Club Member
Callahan Fore
William Sexton
Castor Feinberg
Middle Melissa
Alex Cerdeira
Teen Jamie
Ronda Swindell
Mrs. Ellerbee
Frank Provenzano
Linda's Husband
Kylie Silverstein
Estephania LeBaron - Preteen
Brent Tuccillo
Charlie
Colette Gabrielle
Leonydus Johnson
Tommy Dodd
Jacqueline Kiang
Cody M. Marsh
Young Johnny
Jenny Rodriguez
Search party member
Claudia Sersanti
Blanche
Sally Connors
Mama
Marie Lenzi
Public Defender
Beverly Brooks
Self - Reginald Brook's Ex-Wife
Taylor Henderson
Young Norma Hawkins
Keeley Karsten
Child Pam Sinclair
Melanie Little
Older Cindy
Lilliana Ketchman
Robin Lindsay
Josiah Schneider
Teen James
Wesley Holloway
Jason
Jake Murphy
Teen Brother
Michael DeBarge
Prison Inmate
Steven Strickland
Rachel Oremland
Teen Elizabeth
Brianna Hauser
Young Sheila
Madeline Hoarle
Young Elizabeth
Simone McKnew
Sister
Mark Dancewicz
Ron
Malinda Logan
Felecia Collier
Katelyn Sparks
Pamela Sinclair
Cardin Benjamin
Child Brother
Alphonso Walker Jr.
Aswad Ayinde
Mason Cufari
Roberta's son
Self - Sister
Leah Janvier
Tattletale Sister
Billy Brannigan
Lawrence Harris
Steven Thomas Gamble
Vanessa McMahan
Younger Cindy
James Denzer
Teen Robert
Sophie Maya Spencer
Friend
Emily Nash
Teen Patty
Taylor Scott
Marla Kreuger
Roberta Thompson
Shirley Allen
Remington Ford
Young Gwen
Rachel Eddy
Teenage Daughter
Bruno Pascale
corrections officer
Matthew Chizever
Ed Graf
Paul Noonan
Frank Volpe
Amy's Friend
Charles Manning
David Turpin
Ryan Umbarila
Young Joshua
Heather Hurst
Neighbor
Joanna Pinto
Clare's sister in law
Jordan Allen Bell
Adult Ian Stawicki
Melissa Malone
Kaysi
Lauren Orlando
Sergeant
Aliya Victoriya
Norma Hawkins
Jo Walker
Jamie's Aunt
Henry Eden
Mark
Meridith C. Grundei
Jackie Brown
Elizabeth Flores
Self - Louise Turpin's Sister
Jaden Mcknew
Teenage Son
Kelley Lord
Tonya
Carl Burrows
Paw Paw
Jamie Ragusa
Mama Giles
James Edward Holley
Bob Swanson
Steve Garfanti
Detective #2
Donna Glaesener
Youth Administrator
Frank Osso
Tracey Evans
Counselor
Danitra Faithe
Jackie's Sister
Rachel Gold
Louise Turpin
Giuseppe Virzi
Young - Ian Stawicki
Joan Chak
Mrs. Stawicki
Tiffany Mulan
Alyssa's Sister
Nathaniel Kent
Anthony Lord
Brian Chandler Cook
Joshua Hudnall
Tracey Remarais
Jamie Clark
Anthony Lord's Ex-Girlfriend
Philip Di Maria
Paramedic
Dave Shaver
Marla Krueger
Self - Lawrence Harris' Ex-Wife
Samantha Wendorf
Jordan Turpin
Self - Elizabeth Flores's niece
Matt Rydzewski
Firefighter 1
Regina Gibson
Kathy's Sister
Casey Davis
Levi
Jennifer Bird Pownall
Aaliyah
Clyburn
Jaide Fisher
Teen brother
John Mensah
Soldier
Lori McLeod
Self - Scott Kimball's Ex-Wife
Chrizney Roth
Kat Harris
Jessica McCrorie
Teen Turpin Girl
Tim Kreider
Self - Alec's Father
Jeanetta Turpin
Samantha G Harris
Jamie
Scott Broughton
Scott Kimball
Sabatino Cruz
Young Gene
James Henslee
Self - Junior Lee Beebe's cousin
Joey Gregoire
Young Michael
Kristin Lauria
Alain Laforest
Private Investigator
Justy Kosek
Richard Chandler
Self - William's Son
Self - Elizabeth Flores's sister
William Hudnall
Self - Joshua's Father
Emma R. Mudd
Daycare girl
Julianne Turpin
Messalina Morley
Neighbor 2
Ayanna Hutson
Chester Girlfriend
Self - Elizabeth Flores's brother-in-law
William Knorr
Self - Theresa Knorr's Son
Ivy Bella Fischer
Young Patty
Devin Murphy
Young Karen Gacy
Dominic DiGravio
Alec Kreider
Eric Novak
Younger Walter Stawicki
Michael J. Doherty
Teen Andrew
Anthony Cippola
Justin
BobAndrew Speirs
First Husband of Shirley Allen
Matt Flowers
Charles Sinclair
Johanna Lugo
Clare's Friend
Salvatore Cali
Courtroom Gallery
Olarinde Esuola
Police Officer Garland
Necole Milone
Henry A. Stein
Older Brother as child
Shanisse Palmer
Older Aziza
Emily Olcott
Brittany
Gloria Holmes
Loan Officer
Jessica Turpin
Jennifer Turpin
Jackie Hill
Frank Russo
Andrew H. Rosenbloom
Younger brother
Steve Machita
Mark D. Gersten
Restaurant Patron
Walter Stawicki
Self - Ian's Father
Daniella Wallace
Felicia Daughter
Maurice Carlton
Daddy
Annee Agnello
Ruby Grace
Aziza Kibibi
Joanna Turpin
Evelyn Sabbag
Cindy's Aunt
Taryn Grey
David Segarra
Younger Karl
Sheri Boughner
Self - John Wayne Gacy's Neice
Bryn Berg
Willa Jean
Self - Chester Turner's Ex-Girlfriend
Rich Henkels
Detective #1
Michelle A. Fuller
CSI Tech
Cooper Carrell
Ronald
Julissa Turpin
Jonathan Turpin
Self - Elizabeth Flores's nephew
Self - Lawrence Harris' Sister
D. Scott Johnson
Police Officer #2
Joshua Turpin
Joy Turpin
Self - Ed Graf's Ex-Wife
Kevin B. Mulligan
Congregation member
Kelly Bennett
Adult Elizabeth
Mark A. Gauthier
Chester
George Walsh
Older Karl
Zafina Stewart
Teenage Aziza
Joseph Sean Murphy
Ronald Giles
William Bracker
Vera Kelman
Michael Murphy
Neighborhood
Jolinda Turpin
Self - Shirley Allen's Daughter
Dawn L. Stanley
Katrina Tutschek
Teen Guenevere
Diane Cohen
Mrs. Gacy
James Turpin
Alan Sewell
Neurosurgeon
Kimberly Edwards
Tre Turner
Paramedic #1
Nathan Clarkson
John
Greg Nutcher
Howard Willis
Sage May
Joy's Friend 2
Kathleen Boddington
Debra Newell
Carleigh Johnston
Roy's Niece
Michelle Rae
Vickie Webb
Alessandra Rosenfeld
Young Sister
Marlon Quijije
Richard Girgis
Wendy Heagy
Ariane M. Reinhart
Betty Lou Beets
Tony Brown
Mothers Boyfriend
Laurie Hamfeldt Mahoney
Judith Hawkey
Amanda Tenen
Girlfriend
Samantha Zaino
Teen Sister
Greg Bergman
Detective OReilly
Andrew N Sears
Patrick Alexander (child)
Dwayne R Grant
Intruder
Liz Days
Ariet Girgis
Eli Cox
Biker Buddy
Shannon Mann
Michele Ward
Philip Trossarello
Robert Hawkey
Ben Dawson
Robert Howard Bruce
Kacey Bair
Joy's Friend
John Morgan
Jody
Alex Joseph Theis
Teen Aaron
Caroline J Cassidy
Young Gina
David Schifter
Peewee Gaskins
Peyton Gifis
Young April
Brett Solimine
Det. Barstill
Robyn Babina
Kat Lindsay
Joylynn Martinez
Terra Newell
Self - Debra Newell's Daughter
Jasper Burger
Young Roy
Seth Leighton Hale
Jack Owen Spillman
Emily Peragine
Ashton
Suzanne Armstrong
FBI Chief
Alina Cecilia
Judith's daughter
Liz Burdick
Tim Stainrod
Olivia Vessel
June
Gina Malone
Self - Timothy Bass' Ex-Wife
Lily Anna Schechter
Young Shirley
Deborah Tighe
Suzanne Kipper
Rebekah Madebach
Female Intruder
Ramsey K. Heitmann
Jonh Duck
Alex Schecter
Johnny Knight
Shirley Furgala
Self - Betty Lou Beets' Daughter
Pat MacDonald
Adult Kevin
Nicholas Thomas
Strange Man
Andrew Terranova
Young Ryan
Josh Bernard-Kriegl
Walter Neeley
Lindsey Bryce
Jack Stone
Kevin Duck (teen)
Alex Mestre
Jolene's son
Shirley Gaskins
Self - Donald 'Pee Wee' Gaskins' Daughter
Michael Carr
Robert Foust
Joyce Alexander
Self - William Partrick Alexander's Mother
Ryan Girgis
Self - Magdi Girgis' Son
Ruth Weaver
Self - Paul Keller's Sister
Wilda Gadd
Self - Howard Hawk Willis' Ex-Wife
John Duck
Self - Kevin's Brother
Taylor Woolever
Young May
Devin S. O'Brien
Cop #3
Jackson Davis
Young Bass
Malachi Peters
Bass Webb
Ron Powell
Intruder #2
Julia Beach
Wilda Ellis
Self - Judith's stepson
Self - Robert Howard Bruce's Ex-Wife
Jessi Toronjo
Self - Jeffrey Pelley's Stepsister
Travis Kerr
Donald Gaskins
Roxy Arecco
Adult Sister
Lily Donahue
Amber
Christina Hildreth
Self - Survivor
Tim Halvorsen
Jeff Pelley
Scott Morrell
School principal
Michelle Principi
Roy's Girlfriend
Carmine Giordano
Cop #2
Adam Files
Ronnie
Teri Knight
Self - Manuel Gehring's Ex-Wife
Emmanuel Awe
Tim's Friend
May Sullivan
Self - Roy Spillman's Sister
Robin Healey
Isabelle Ballard
Kim Ghelkins
Self - Bass Webb's Mother
Self - Richard Daniel Starrett's Ex-Wife
Colleen McGloin
Mother in law
Ben Keller
Self - Paul Keller's Brother
Spencer Dunn
April Steele
Felipe Caita
Jonathan Ridore
Young Travis
Steve Strom
Principal
Brooke Rochman
Self - Voice Over Talent
Self - Aaron Foust's Father
Richard Rouse
Self - Pastor, Trinity Lutheran Church
Travis Spencer
Self - Timothy Wilson Spencer's Brother
Charlotte Fountain-Jardim
Alanna Smith
Belinda
Ethan Mathias
Young Daniel
Sam Duncan
Child Matt
Ricky Lewis
Detective Gleeson
Anthony Carvello
Peter Avsenew
Francesca Rain
Young sister to Camellia Brown
Hudson Barry
Peter
Felice Kakaletris
Emma 2021
Rocco Palmieri
Matt Roth
Adam Courtney
Child Michael
Dave Morrissey Jr.
Donald
Kyle Dunn
Eric
Nikki Neurohr
Sharon Morris
Tim Shelburne
Robert Walden
Kike Ayodeji
Patrick's Sister-In-Law
Lauren Pisano
Stacy Kuykendall
Self - Cameron Todd Willingham's Ex-Wife
Richard Bird
Dad
Indiana Arnold
Daniel's Brother, Neighbor Bitten by Dog
Javan Nelson
Robert Brasher
Jocelyne O'Toole
Waitress
Jacqueline O'Kelly
Rose Marie Brashers
Drew Levy
Teen Mike
Michael Ignatow
Self - Melvin Ignatow's Son
Natasha Walfall
Kelly Pletcher
Self - Wayne Adam Ford's Ex-Wife
Cathy Mills
Self - Robert Walden's Ex-Wife
Daniel Rolle
Self - Donald Rolle's Son
Deborah Brashers
Self - Robert Eugene Brashers' Daughter
Vincent Gruosso
Kenneth Roth
Cecilia Kurachi Ubé
Sonja Holt
Self - Stafford Shaw's Ex-Fiancé
Daniel Williams
Cedric
Mia Fowler
Teshana
Yael Fern
Adult Cindy
Daniel Alatorre
Young Cristobal
Belinda Christopher
Self - Eric Nance's Sister
Sandra Marante
Christina Gaines
Mike Magliocca
Wayne Adam Ford
Julia Maggiola
Mindy
Self - Edward Allen Covington's Ex-Wife
Teshana Singleton
Self - Cedric Rick's Ex-Wife
Self - Patrick Fowler's Ex-Girlfriend
Self - Kenneth Roth's Adopted Son
Robyn Barry
Self - Craig Thrift's Ex-Wife
Joe Alo
Cousin Tony
Self - Dylan Eason's Father
Claire Throssell
Self - Ex-Wife of Darren Sykes
Sarah Garone
Self - Gary Hardy's Stepdaughter
Valerie Saturno
Jennifer Winter
Asher Edgecliffe-Johnson
Young Peter
Self - Anthony Fiebiger's Ex-Boyfriend
Self - Cristobal Palacio's Ex-Wife
Oliver Comstock Reynolds
Darren Sykes
Ammie Turos
Self - Christian Fuhr's Ex-Girlfriend
Kelsey Nichole Black
Claire
Cely Riva
Patrick's Ex
Kristian Sorensen
Adult Daniel
Cindy Blust
Self - Camellia Brown's Sister
Chelsea Diane
Jealous Co-Worker
Emmanuel Almonte
David's Friend
Alden Walcott
Young Girl
Emma Pearson
Alice
Amber Leanne Rothberg
Teen Amy
Brandon Keeton
Kaan Akyol
Military Police
Dylan LaRay
Cop
Liz Bishop
Morgan's Mom
Mark Willis
Ex-Boyfriend
Dupree Francois Porter
Steve
Quinn McCarthy
Child Amy
Jim Brannigan
Priest
Carter Meehan
Morgan's Son
Henry Glendon Walter V
Child David
Zachary Garmers
Chadney
Kennedy Long
Koi
Nathan Simpson
Chris Matechen
Kathy Huynh-Phan
Daycare Worker 2
Melody Ladd
Alice Jenkins
Theodore Dalton
Sharief Johnson
Greg
Hana Leigh
Vicki Jensen
Aaron Shuf
Young Benji
Alvin Christmas
Vern
Kenneth Andrew
Adult Sam
Lara Fox
Benji's mother Beth
Flynn Lantz
Joey Preston
Sarah Ann Leahy
Patty
Lauren Hart
Charmar Jeter
Theresa Burns
Diane
Aislinn Yakira Otero
Linda Bergstrom
Summer Stern
Marissa
Jacob Applegate
Adult David Schafer
Christon Andell
Steve's Friend
Jesse Eging
Self - Mary Rowles' Son
Andrew Chan-Possemato
Young Jordyn
Amy Chesler
Self - Jesse Winnick's Sister
Hannah Eakin
Laurel Brower
Steven Curtis Jones
Garrett Taylor
Tony Alamo
James Brickhouse
Police Officer 2
Rae-Shan Barclift
Sam Christie
Self - Ernest Christie's Son
Riley Robinson
Katie Lewis
Adult Amy
Damien Galvez
Chad
Amanda Daniel
Miranda Powers
Sandy
Isabella Carter
Seamstress
Dean McDonald
Young Adam
Marie-Kaniyah Porter
Young Kara
Lucas Toll Luchsinger
Benji (teen)
Daniel Allitt
Young Dustin
Kate Odulukwe
Courtney Dease
James
Timothy Phillips Jr.
Teen Steve
Jennifer Meyer
Self - Former Partner
Kaizo Kim
ICU Doctor
Harkeim Wray
Teen Bryant
Cormac Joyce
Ernest
Peter Tedeschi
Mr. Woods
Shane Velez
Chief Detective
Jordan Moeller
Adult Thom
Victor Del Rio
Firefighter
McKenna Bintz
Jacob Lynn
Sean Paul Mack
Carlos Morrow
Michael O'Leary
Annie Tisdale
Susan
Greg Hoffman
Brenda Dettrey
Western Bar Patron
Yvonne YF Chan
Sungnam Kwon-Lisowski
Lynden Miles Ley
Young David
Arkira Chantaratananond
Delilah Yang
Sean Forest Kiefer
Luis
Adam J. Jackson
Andrei Dolezal
Marc O'Leary
Keeley Shantz
Tyler's Sister
Bella Porraro
Victoria - Adult
Maddie Dyer
Young Diane
Jenn Nobile
Margie Bult
Timira Robinson
Almog Pail
Lori
Matt Langer
Caitlin McWethy
Marie
Samantha Kudler
Rebecca
Michelle Atiemo
Madison Mitts
Duane's Girlfriend
Kendyl Thakral
Tammy
Joseph Dean Anderson
John White
Skylar Clifford
Young Christine Lisowski
Stephanie Mautone
Carolyn Holland
Tyler's Mom
Emma Fagerstrom
Kelly
Melanie San Millan
Dianne
Jackie Kuczinski
Genie
Avril Kagan
Child Karen
Amanda Dempsey
Karina
Kevin Oko
Young Mark
Michele Danna
Margie's Friend
Catherine Wilson
Eloise Ro
Elana Valastro
Peta
Mckinnley Nelson
Teen Vince
Jaren Anderson
Gene
Aliza Cocchiola
Young Victoria
Tay Witcher
Aunt
Kristan David Curry
Parole Officer
Isabelle Hou
Maline
Charlie Patton
Tyler (Teen)
Kevin Fitzpatrick
Chloé Jean-Miles
Young Teressa
Craig Bradstock
Kyle Portela
Tyler's Friend #1
Genoveva Rossi
Coach Harris
Noah Mendes
Little Brother
Eli D Goss
Emma Lockhart
Tonja Balden
Bettina Skye
Preachers Wife
Lauren Lyons
Brooke Weber
Julie Chapin
Alice Stock
Skylar Smith
Young Joy
Kat Tramantano
Female Detective
Amelia Still
Teen Elishaba
Ani Pellegrino
Desiree
Rhi Brown
Shelley Molad
Nita
Diana Aras
Paramedic 1
Sammy Smedley
Ainjil
Dallas Grant
Adam Alpert
Timothy Milano
Noah Eisenstein
Jimmy
Charlotte Ewing
Young Crystal
Courtney Autera
Teen Liana
Melissa Ford
Rafaella Karnaby
Young Heather
Taylor Hadsell
Susan Paerels
Seven James
Nathan
Amy Simon
Austin Kirk
David
Carolyne Leys
Lori Lucas
Adam Lucas
Teen Roger
Petra Denison
Joy Hoop
Johnny Travers
Ron Youngblood
Brent Bruckner
Uncle
Chris Smith
Teacher Referee
Brittany Gautier
Brandi Worley
Shane Stone
Police Officer #3
Michelle Feza Kuchuk
Mama Rose
Grant VanderVoort
Gary Simmons
Ann Marie Taglavore
Debra
David Ranan Ellner
Jeffrey Wolfe
Paula Lima
Veronica Youngblood
Rahim Rosen
Casino patronuncredited
Lynn Marocola
Police Officeruncredited
Roger Brenner
Uniformed Police Officeruncredited
Bob Leszczak
Bar Patronuncredited
Xaiver Gerald
Studentuncredited
Jennifer Agatte
Waitressuncredited
Sean Prasso
Ellen McAlpine
Beautiful Hitchhikeruncredited
Alec Tincher
Boyfrienduncredited
Charlotte Shovilin
Robin's Daughteruncredited
Sloane Wolfe
Child Sisteruncredited
Mike Olivieri
Detectiveuncredited
J Brian
Robin's Fatheruncredited
Nixon Frederick
Fatheruncredited
Danielle Barrett
Deborahuncredited
Zack Rudolph
Cop #1uncredited
Shefik
Barbershop Client #2uncredited