Elenco (na ordem dos créditos)
John Homa
Self - Judge
Shawnee Smith
Self - Host
James Gunn
Lindsay Felton
Self
Tanedra Howard
Michelle Galdenzi
Jaime King
Jaina Lee Ortiz
Gabby West
Tim Sullivan
Christine Haeberman
Angela Anderson
Tai Davis
Jessica Palette
Sierra Holmes
Sarah Agor
Sarah Alami
Lina So
Allison Kyler
Marissa Skell
Brandon Ellison
Head Vampire
Karlie Redd
Trevor Wright
Caleb Emerson
Homicidal Maniac
Kylah Kim
Rosanna Pansino
Nathan Barnatt
Mime
Michael Rooker
Sean Gunn
Self - Guest
Brooke Lewis Bellas
Vampire's Assistant Amanda
Nick Hawk
Kelly Wagner
Katie Eischen
Greg Gayne
Jo-Anne Krupa
Jennifer Gable
Screamer
Debbie Rochon
Self - Guest Judge
Heath Freeman
Darren Lynn Bousman
Mark Burg
Joe Wengert
Lana Underwood
Bru Muller
Adam Sampson
Chris Edwards